Background
22 January 2013, 10.00–17.30
Bibliothéque Solvay, Rue Belliard 137, Leopold Park, 1040 Brussels
About the seminar
The seminar was arranged by the European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (eceee) in cooperation with the Swedish Energy Agency and CLASP Europe with additional support from Energifonden.
Background
Minimum energy performance requirements and energy labels are usually considered to have many virtues such as reducing consumer bills, limiting fuel dependency and creating jobs. One recurrent question is about their impact on and interplay with innovation. The recent IFA electronics and appliance fair in Berlin has again confirmed that western manufacturers strongly compete on innovation. Innovation is key for the competitiveness of the industry, and the EU intends to accelerate eco-innovation through well-targeted policies.
An argument often heard to oppose stringent energy performance regulations on products is the risk of being too prescriptive on technologies, thus forcing manufacturers to use costly sub-optimal or proprietary technologies and hampering ‘natural’ innovation.
On the contrary, promoters of such product regulations usually consider them as innovation stimulators that help accelerating the deployment and reducing the cost of innovative technologies. They often regret that this positive innovation effect is insufficiently anticipated in the level of ambition of the policy instruments.
An evaluation study on the EU Ecodesign Directive in 2011 has not identified so far evidence that manufacturers have a harder time innovating under the constraints of the policy. Only a few firms were reported to complain that the requirements may inhibit the development of additional functions. On the contrary, interviews from stakeholders suggested a positive role for the Directive in the development of innovation. Does this mean that decision-makers could have been less shy in ambition, considering this feed-back?
Answering this question supposes to have a good understanding of the dynamics of innovation driven by policy intervention. This is still an understudied area. When discussing the level of stringency of energy performance requirements, analysts often look at static snapshots of a given technology’s development and often do a poor job predicting its future. A well-known example is how underestimated the deployment of LED backlighting has been in the preparation of the Ecodesign measure for TVs, leading to poorly effective requirements. Estimates primarily based on engineering approaches often lead to dramatic overestimation of the difficulty or costs to comply.
Solutions have been suggested to better account for the dynamics of innovation. First, decision-making processes should be swifter and rely on very recent data. Technology and price forecasting should be more grounded on experience curves and market-based approaches. One particular issue for the Ecodesign Directive has been the disappointing role of benchmarks up to this point, which were one of the tools expected to stimulate innovation. The introduction of longer-term Ecodesign requirements based on benchmarks can be considered desirable, in the spirit of so-called ‘technology-forcing standards’.
Now that some Ecodesign regulations start to produce their effects, what can be said about their impact on innovation? Is this impact adequately accounted for in the revised methodology used by the EU for future preparatory studies and decision-making? Could this increased knowledge lead to bolder and more effective regulations?










