Columnists: Dario Di Santo, FIRE
Published on: 30 Oct 2026
Making energy policies work over time: lessons from Italian White Certificates, Part 2
A policy can have sound objectives, significant technical potential and robust rules and still run into difficulties. As discussed in the previous article, the Italian White Certificate scheme shows that turning energy-saving potential into projects depends on rules, transaction costs, support, skills and learning time. But there is a second challenge: once a policy is working, it must remain credible and workable as conditions change. This brings confidence, market response, governance and regulatory stability to the fore.
Trust also delivers results
Confidence among market actors is crucial. During the crisis of the White Certificate scheme, high rejection rates and uncertainty in the interpretation of rules increased the risks associated with developing projects. That risk came at a cost and contributed to the collapse in supply.
Among other measures, the 2021 reform introduced preliminary procedures allowing operators to engage with GSE, the managing authority, before formally submitting a project and obtain feedback on key aspects. The aim is simple: identify potential issues earlier and reduce uncertainty.
The first results have been encouraging, also thanks to accompanying measures introduced in the same period. After years in which rejection rates had in some cases exceeded 50%, GSE data available in 2026 showed that only 1% of applications received a negative assessment. At the time the paper was written, all applications preceded by a preliminary request had received a positive outcome.
A high approval rate is not, in itself, evidence of good regulation. It does, however, show how clarity, early engagement and predictability can affect a policy’s ability to generate projects. Clear rules also reduce the administrative costs and burden borne by the authority managing the scheme.
Price alone does not solve everything
White Certificates also highlight a limitation of market mechanisms in energy policy. When certificate supply became insufficient, prices rose rapidly. Higher prices should have encouraged new projects and additional supply, but the response was much weaker than might have been expected if supply had been sufficiently elastic.
The reason is straightforward. A complex industrial project does not materialise because the price of a certificate rises today. The opportunity must be identified and developed, the measurement system designed, the project submitted and approved, the investment implemented and, finally, its performance assessed. The process can easily take two or three years. If operators also lack confidence in the stability of the rules or the likelihood of approval, a higher price may still not compensate for the perceived risk. This was precisely the situation between 2015 and 2021.
Market mechanisms remain useful tools, but they do not govern themselves. Targets need to be consistent with the actual capacity of the supply side, while continuous monitoring and the possibility of intervention are needed when structural imbalances emerge.
A system that is getting back on track?
Recent signals are encouraging, but should be interpreted with caution. Applications and the use of preliminary procedures have increased, approval rates have improved and the market has moved towards more balanced conditions. New certificate generation is recovering more slowly, as expected given the time lag between improving project conditions and generating savings. The real test will come as projects developed under the old rules progressively decline and the scheme has to rely increasingly on new ones.
A lesson that goes beyond White Certificates
After more than twenty years, perhaps the most important lesson is that a good policy is not simply a well-drafted piece of legislation. It is a system of objectives, procedures, incentives, market actors, public authorities and behaviours that change over time and interact with one another. Guidelines, technical assistance, stakeholder dialogue and monitoring are therefore not ancillary elements: they are part of the policy itself.
This is why regulatory stability – understood as a clearly defined multi-year framework within which individual rules can and should evolve – is as important as the quality of the original measure. Stability does not mean changing rules continuously to follow the market, nor does it mean leaving them untouched. Policies need to be predictable enough to allow investment, while remaining capable of learning from results and adjusting when reality departs from the assumptions on which they were built.
This also places responsibilities on both sides. Policymakers need to manage the policies they introduce over time and intervene when circumstances require it. Sector stakeholders, meanwhile, need a broader perspective so that their proposals are not driven solely by narrow short-term interests, but by the ability of policies to support the growth of businesses and the wider system over the medium and long term.
Because a good policy should not simply distribute incentives or impose obligations, but help businesses, market actors and the skills needed to achieve its objectives grow over time.










