Columnists: Anibal T. De Almeida, University of Coimbra
Published on: 20 Oct 2026
Non-energy benefits play a major role in the cost-benefit assessment of motor system optimization with a huge savings potential
According to IEA, electric motors already consume more than half of the total electricity used to drive a multiple variety of end-uses. The projected massive increase in desalination and in cooling/refrigeration loads will increase even more the role of motors. Energy-efficient motor systems can save over 30% of the consumed electricity. When carrying energy and non-energy cost-benefit assessment of motor system optimization, to support the design of new systems or the upgrade of existing ones, there have been difficulties in assessing the role of non-energy benefits, due to their variability according to specific conditions (e.g. sector, technology, type of application, operation conditions).
A major review "Energy and non-energy cost-benefit assessment of motor system optimization” has developed a novel cost-benefit assessment methodology and model supported by a large variety of over 400 case studies around the World. The study was carried out by an international team from ISR-University of Coimbra (Portugal), LBL-University of Berkeley (USA) and University of Mato Grosso (Brazil). The model allows analysis based on specific conditions (e.g. sector, technology, operating conditions). Although there are variations for different applications, it was found out that Energy and Non-energy benefits have similar magnitude in relation to energy benefits, both in the industrial and in tertiary-commercial sector applications – this means on average cutting the payback time by around 50%, providing much stronger support to increased motor system optimization application around the World.
The scientific relevance of the study lies in connecting two research areas that are commonly treated separately: energy efficiency and non-energy benefits. Rather than reviewing technologies alone, the paper translates evidence on reliability, maintenance, downtime, safety, noise, and process stability into a common economic assessment. This addresses a methodological gap between engineering performance analysis and investment decision-making. Its sector-sensitive approach recognizes that identical technologies can produce different economic outcomes depending on operating conditions, production requirements, and the consequences of equipment failure.
Methodology
The proposed methodology introduces a Non-Energy Benefit Monetization Index, or NEBMI. Six benefit categories receive intensity scores from zero to three, representing absent to high benefits. These scores are combined using economic weights and normalized to produce an index between zero and one. A scaling factor then converts the index into an estimated ratio of non-energy benefits to energy benefits. Combining this ratio with electricity cost savings enables calculation of total benefits and revised financial indicators. The framework integrates case-study evidence with United States Department of Energy estimates across industrial and commercial subsectors.
An important methodological feature is its use of adjustable weights, conservative scaling factors, and sensitivity analysis. Downtime, reliability, and process stability receive substantial importance because they directly affect production and service continuity. However, the authors explicitly acknowledge that these parameters are evidence-informed defaults rather than universal empirical coefficients. Consequently, the framework provides a practical starting point for assessment, while requiring calibration against local maintenance records, production losses, operating conditions, and verified performance. Its scientific contribution is therefore a structured decision-support methodology rather than definitive measurement of every benefit.
Technically, the paper supports optimizing the complete motor-driven system. Relevant interventions include correct equipment sizing, IE3–IE5 motors, permanent-magnet and synchronous reluctance technologies, variable speed drives, efficient mechanical transmissions, improved pumps and fans, and digital monitoring. System integration is particularly important because efficient motors alone cannot eliminate losses caused by oversized equipment, inefficient transmissions, throttling, or unnecessary operation. Variable speed control offers substantial savings in centrifugal pumps and fans, where power requirements approximately follow the cube of rotational speed under suitable operating conditions.
Beyond energy performance, optimization can reduce mechanical stress, operating temperatures, failures, and maintenance requirements while improving process control and product quality. Sensors and diagnostic analytics support predictive maintenance and earlier detection of abnormal conditions. The paper reports examples of extended maintenance intervals and improved operational continuity. Economically, incorporating non-energy benefits can substantially increase project value and, across the authors’ case-study-based assessment, reduce estimated payback periods by approximately 50% on average under conservative assumptions. These findings explain why investments appearing marginal from electricity savings alone may become attractive when operational benefits are included.
Electricity Savings an Environmental Impacts
The environmental significance reflects the scale of motor electricity demand. The manuscript estimates that motor-driven systems consume approximately 53% of global electricity, equivalent to 17.000 TWh annually in 2025. It cites an ambitious global optimization scenario yielding 3.100 TWh of annual savings by 2040 and approximately 1.04 billion tonnes of avoided carbon dioxide emissions. These are scenario-based projections, based on IEA load growth data, dependent on adoption and electricity generation carbon intensity. Additional potential benefits include reduced generation-related air pollution and water demand, less waste heat, longer equipment life, and lower material replacement requirements.
Overall, the study positions motor system optimization as a combined productivity, competitiveness, and decarbonization strategy. Its framework can help engineers, facility managers, financial officers, and policymakers compare technologies and prioritize investments using broader lifecycle value. The principal limitation remains uncertainty in monetizing non-energy benefits and transferring case-study findings between applications.










