Search eceee proceedings

Comparing FT-crude and methanol processing for production of synthetic fuels (kerosene, diesel, gasoline, naphtha)

Panel: 1. Processes and technologies to meet future challenges

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Natalia Pieton, Germany

Abstract

Motivation and main objectives

With a PtL study published in 2016 [1], the German government suggests two pathways for the production of synthetic kerosene, which are both based on green hydrogen: The Fischer Tropsch (FT) synthesis and the Methanol-to-Synfuels (MtS) pathway.

Thus, the objective is to assesses the techno economic differences between the FT and MtS pathway and to answer the following two research questions:

1. How do both pathways compare technically?

2. How do both pathways compare economically?

3. Are German synfuel plants competitive to production in countries with high Renewable Energy (RE) potentials, considering use of existing assets for fuels production and imports of hydrogen and CO2, or FT crude or methanol?

Methodological approach

– An extensive and systematic literature review is conducted to compare the FT and MtS pathway for production of synthetic kerosene, diesel, gasoline, and naphtha qualitatively

– This literature is used to extract economically related parameters to the production of Synfuels.

– These cost parameters are further used to create a cost tool, that is able to compare synfuel production between the FT and MtS pathway, different capacities and locations for electricity generation from RE.

Results and conclusions

Considering a far-reaching electrification to achieve climate neutrality and the associated decreasing demand for gasoline and diesel in road transport, as well as heating oil in the heat sector, fuel production will probably be limited to kerosene and marine diesel. The Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (FT synthesis) and methanol-to-synfuels pathway can be considered for synthetic fuel production (kerosene, diesel). Biomass-based pathways are excluded from this analysis, but may play a relevant role. Platform chemicals, nowadays derived from naphtha, will continue to be in high demand in the future, but are secondary in volume compared to fuel demand. These can be produced either from the co-product naphtha from FT synthesis or via the methanol-to-olefins (MtO) pathway. This clearly shows that methanol can be applied as a versatile feedstock.

Nevertheless, FT synthesis is a commercially established process to output kerosene, diesel, gasoline, and naphtha from fossil syngas (a gaseous mix of mainly hydrogen and carbon monoxide). FT-crude is an intermediate product very similar to crude oil. The MtS pathway has the potential to output the same kind of fuel range as the FT process but it has more process steps and has not been industrially applied yet. Few is reported in literature on the MtS pathway. Methanol itself is a commodity chemical, which is made from fossil syngas nowadays.

The results have shown that FT and MtS have comparable production costs for synfuels on a greenfield and green hydrogen production has the highest cost share in synfuels production, but plants capacities for the synthesis of syngas to FT-crude or methanol can also have a significant impact on overall synfuel production costs. When comparing production of methanol or FT synfuels in countries with high RE potentials, only plant capacities of medium sizes are considered. In some cases, plant capacities were not taken into account at all. Thus, existing refineries, which might have relevant infrastructure for synfuels production and substantial capacities could act as key enabler for domestic synfuels production from FT crude.

References

[1] GERMAN ENVIRONMENT AGENCY: Power-to-Liquids: Potentials and Perspectives (2016). URL https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/377/publikationen/161005_uba_hintergrund_ptl_barrierrefrei.pdf – Überprüfungsdatum 2022-09-18

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-035-23_Pieton_Pres.pdf