Search eceee proceedings

The electrification of heat consumption in the paper industry: Two case studies on the implementation of high temperature heat pumps and thermoelectric storage

Panel: 1. Processes and technologies to meet future challenges

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Giuseppe Bonforte, Renovit, Italy Chiara Spinelli, Renovit, Italy

Abstract

Over the last couple of years, achieving decarbonization has become a high priority for the European industry. Indeed, all sectors of the economy are constantly subject to a push and pull effect: as the ‘Fit for 55’ package has stepped up the EU policy climate ambition, the bar of minimum legal requirements companies must comply with is raising, pushing all sectors towards faster improvements. Simultaneously, on the pull side, a confluence of market factors – including the escalating demand for low-carbon products, the rising tide of the EU Taxonomy and the increased attention towards Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) – forces industries towards sustainable practices. The answer to this landscape can be nothing but drastic transformations, although tailored to industry-specific processes.

Among the most energy-intensive sectors, this paper takes a deep-dive into the pulp and paper industry, projecting potential pathways forward for the sector to reach the full decarbonization. According to CEPI (Confederation of European Paper Industries, Key Statistics 2022), the paper sector counted 664 companies, responsible for a primary energy consumption of 1.203.963 TJ. While GHG emissions have seen a significant decrease (29% from 2005 to date), the path towards net-zero carbon solutions is still uphill.

After a short introduction on the current state of the state of the art, the presentation will illustrate a technical-economic feasibility study aimed to evaluate two innovative technologies to enhance energy efficiency and reduce environmental impact of the paper industry. The first considered technology involves the installation of high-temperature heat pumps that can use the waste heat from process flue water for steam production. This approach, based on the efficient utilization of thermal resources already present in the production process, has the potential to significantly increase the overall efficiency of the plant.

The second technology is a thermoelectric storage system (TESS), focused on the production of "green" steam. This innovative system utilizes the storage of renewable electrical energy in the form of heat, through a fluidized bed of sand. This approach allows for the storage of electric energy during periods of overproduction or low demand, subsequently converting it into usable steam in paper production whenever needed providing a lower environmental impact and a greater operational flexibility for the plant.

The assessment of the technical-economic feasibility of both technologies involves a series of key parameters. Firstly, the technical characteristics of high-temperature heat pumps will be analyzed, considering their integration into the existing plant and their impact on the daily operations of the paper mill. Environmental implications, in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and the overall environmental footprint, will also be examined.

The same approach will be used for thermoelectric storage as the analysis will focus on the system's ability to efficiently store and release energy, considering variations in the plant's energy demand. Economic impact will also be evaluated, including investment, operational and maintenance costs over the project lifetime.

In both cases, financing scenarios, government incentives, and return on investment periods will be considered to provide a comprehensive view of the economic feasibility of each technology. The potential synergy between the two technologies will be examined to maximize overall benefits for the paper mill.

The study shows that the technologies are already a technically and economically viable solution, while offering valuable insights to the discourse on the feasibility of the industrial full decarbonization in the broader context of achieving the EU's ambitious climate targets.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-020-23_Bonforte_Pres.pdf