Search eceee proceedings
The promise of industrial demand-side flexibility: findings from a qualitative study
Panel: 2. Energy management and corporate culture
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Jessica Berneiser, Fraunhofer Institut für Solare Energiesysteme ISE, Germany
Leonard Schneider-Strehl, Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems ISE, Germany
Johanna Kucknat, Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems ISE, Germany
Moritz Vogel, Öko-Institut e.V.
Sebastian Gölz, Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems ISE, Germany
Abstract
Decarbonizing energy-intensive industry is an important step for tackling climate change. This involves different measures, such as increasing energy efficiency, but also the direct (e.g., heat pumps) and indirect (e.g., H2) electrification of industrial processes. Decarbonization scenarios that integrate electrification as an essential decarbonization option show that the demand for electricity from renewable energies (RE) will increase considerably. An energy system that is increasingly based on RE is characterized by fluctuations in RE production. Ensuring a reliable and uninterrupted energy supply is key for operating many industrial processes. Shifting electricity consumption to periods with abundant RE generation, so-called demand-side flexibility, or demand response (DR) helps to reduce burden on the power grid and contributing to its reliability by balancing out disproportional fluctuations in energy supply and demand. Furthermore, by actively managing and optimizing electricity consumption, companies can profit from low electricity prices in times of high RE electricity generation.
However, since transformation processes for decarbonizing, especially electrifying, industrial processes have only started, it remains unclear so far, how great the actual potential of demand response in the German industry is. Until now, various studies on barriers and possible negative effects to industrial flexibility exist, such as loss of production, reduced product quality, and impact on working hours.
In a qualitative study we thus examined whether flexibility is an important issue for companies in the German energy-intensive industry. Furthermore, we assessed which factors are associated with industrial companies’ strategies, engagement, and decisions to make their production processes more flexible in the future. 14 qualitative interviews were conducted with representatives from energy-intensive companies in 2023. One main finding was that companies had different understandings of flexibility in our sample, such as flexibility as demand response (timely shift of production), as hybridization (bi- or multivalent energy supply) and as energy storage. Perceived relevance of flexibility in their different understandings displays mixed results, ranging from companies tending not to consider participating in respective forms of flexibility provision and others considering their application or already adopting them. In terms of relevant factors influencing companies' flexibility decisions, grid volatility at the macro level incentivizes companies to flexibilize their energy procurement, while current regulations in the energy sector create disincentives that hinder flexibility. At the meso level, inflexibility of the technological setting as well as organizational effort are perceived as inhibiting factors, however, a culture of innovation constitutes a decisive flexibility driver. Regarding the perspective of the individual company members (micro level), necessary behavioral changes, competence deployment and the acceptance of increasingly flexible working hours in new shift systems prove to be highly relevant.
To conclude, flexibility seems to be a topic among the German energy-intensive industries, yet the understanding of flexibility concepts as well as the extent and perceived relevance of flexibility provision differ strongly between companies. In addition to the creation of suitable framework conditions at a higher political level, the design of business models and the focus on innovation at company level can also be decisive in exploiting the potential for flexibility. Finally, this study highlights, that flexibility in energy-intensive industries through demand response requires far-reaching changes for flexible production and work organization.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 2-048-23_Berneiser_Pres.pdf

























