Search eceee proceedings

A step towards decarbonization of steel industry: an open discussion on how to pave the way to consistent and meaningful energy performance indicators

Panel: 3. Drivers to change

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Rashida Khalid, University of Pavia, Italy Norma Anglani, University of Pavia, Italy Vincenzo Catania, Collarini Energy Consulting, Italy

Abstract

According to the World Steel Association, the production of crude steel was 165.1 million tonnes (Mt) in March 2023, which is an increase of 1.7 Mt as compared with March 2022. Additionally, according to the Iron and Steel Roadmap of the IEA (October 2020), the energy intensity of the steel sector shall decrease from the current 18.9 GJ/t to 17.2 by 2030 to 14.8 by 2050. The scope of this work is methodological: it has to represent the first step towards investigating the application of an energy management system, certified according to UNI CEI EN ISO 50001 and ISO 14064, with the target of setting up and monitoring meaningful energy indicators, by analyzing the concepts behind the proposed scheme. ISO 50001 specifies the standards to improve the energy management systems through the method: plan, do, check, and act methodology. ISO 14064 gives insight into direct (scope 1), and indirect (scope 2, scope 3) greenhouse gas emissions. Integration of ISO 14064 with ISO 50001 can give more insight into the energy performance indicators (EnPIs). For successful industrial energy management defining accurate EnPIs is compulsory.

For the effective implementation of energy efficiency, meaningful data is required from the general energy audits to the detailed process data. This study discusses the method to identify the EnPIs at a process level for a typical electric arc furnace-based steel mill. We aim at identifying three selected boundary levels: at (i) mill level, (ii) system flows, and (iii) process, by adapting what is proposed in [1] for kraft pulp mills.

In the first step the process level is categorized based on the services i.e.(i) main activities, (ii) auxiliary services, and (iii) general services with respect to each activity: that is steel making, hot rolling, forging, etc. Each activity needs to be placed under a process level. The activities are categorized into n numbers and each activity has m equipment. In the second step, different EnPIs are computed for each activity for each energy carrier. and, if possible, compared with similar indicators available from literature and this is done for each energy carrier available in the mill. In the third step, energy- intensive activities are identified based on the energy management system according to ISO 50001 by merging information. This step takes into account the annual energy consumption, availability of the monitoring system, and technological adequacy of the user system. The result provides a ranking of activities according to low, medium, and high energy-intensive levels. By comparing the results of EnPIs with the literature, the indicators are obtained at global and process levels in each activity.

The contribution of this work is to share challenges and potentials of a detailed study of a steel mill and insights on how to update the EnPIs, in order to be functional to a real decarbonization path. The main pitfalls in identifying the EnPIs is the unavailability of detailed data, when the data from the monitoring is not qualitatively superior and thus choices on how to decompose have to be made.

Acknowledgement: The study is funded by PNRR, DM352/2022 in collaboration with University of Pavia and Collarini Energy Consulting.

Index Terms—Decarbonization, Steel, EnPIs, ISO 50001,

[1] E. Andersson, H. Dernegård, M. Wallén, and P. Thollander, “Decar- bonization of industry: Implementation of energy performance indicators for successful energy management practices in kraft pulp mills,” Energy Reports, vol. 7, pp. 1808–1817, 2021.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-049-23_Khalid_Pres.pdf