Search eceee proceedings
Comparison of Subsidy Schemes for the Decarbonization of Industry in the EU
Panel: 3. Drivers to change
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Robin Blömer, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Johannes Eckstein, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Abstract
The EU ETS is the cornerstone for emission reduction in industry and electricity generation in the EU, as it incentivizes cost-efficient emission reduction. However, this instrument has some conceptual drawbacks when incentivizing investments in fundamentally new decarbonization technologies. The uncertain CO2 price development creates investment risks that increase financing costs. Furthermore, investments in transformative technologies with higher abatement costs are not enabled by the EU ETS. Consequently, some complementary policy instruments have been introduced that aim to subsidize clean production technologies. In this study we aim to evaluate the suitability of such policies, with a focus on the EU Innovation Fund (IF) grants program, the Dutch SDE++ scheme and the German CCfD scheme called “Klimaschutzverträge” (KSV).
After analyzing the challenges in industrial decarbonization and shortcomings of current regulation, assessment criteria for decarbonization schemes are derived. Subsequently, this study comparatively analyses the design of the three schemes and evaluates how suitable the design of each scheme is based on the derived criteria.
Based on literature review we apply the following criteria to evaluate the three subsidy schemes. Firstly, the effectiveness of the scheme is assessed by analyzing the contribution towards the policy goal. Secondly, economic efficiency is evaluated based on static allocation efficiency, incentive compatibility, risk distribution, transaction costs and market distortion. The third criterion is the transformational effect. It evaluates dynamic efficiency and support of technologies crucial to reach long-term policy goals. Lastly, sustainability in a wider scope, meaning accessibility and creating a level-playing field for all actors, as well as supporting environmental sustainability is assessed.
The EU IF grants support decarbonization projects in emissions-intensive industries and the energy sector. Its overall goal is bringing technologies to market in first-of-kind implementations. The applied award criteria reflect this main goal at the expense of static efficiency, by giving effectiveness, replicability, project maturity and degree of innovation the same weighting as cost efficiency (20% each). Additionally, a cost-based approach to determining funding compromises the incentives for efficient design and operation.
The main goal of SDE++ is cost-efficient emission reduction in energy generation and carbon capture and storage technologies via a price-only auction. The support is paid via a sliding market premium (single-sided CfD). This leads to a risk hedge and static cost efficiency but entails the risk of only supporting established technologies with low abatement costs.
The German CCfD schemes (KSV) is designed to support transformative technologies in all energy-intensive industries via a Carbon Contract for Difference (CCfD) and includes energy price hedging. Bids are scored partly within sectors. This reduces cost efficiency as not the cheapest overall bids, but the most economic per sector are awarded. On the other hand, this is suitable to initiate transformation in all sectors.
In conclusion, the analysis shows similarities, but also major differences between the schemes. As the scope and allocation mechanism differ, the outcomes are expected to diverge. However, each is suited to pursue its main goal. This result emphasizes that the goal of such schemes should be aligned with the overall policy mix. As the ETS provides incentives for cost-efficient emission abatement, complementary subsidy schemes, which focus on supporting efficient transformative technologies, seem more stringent. Furthermore, the qualitative results indicate a need for quantitative analysis of the outcome of the schemes.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 3-038-23_Blomer_Pres.pdf

























