Search eceee proceedings
Decarbonisation of the German Glass Industry
Panel: 3. Drivers to change
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Peter Radgen, University of Stuttgart, Institute for Enery Economics and Rational Energy Use (IER), Germany
Matthias Leisin, University of Stuttgart, Institute for Enery Economics and Rational Energy Use (IER), Germany
Johann Overath, BV Glas, Germany
Abstract
Germany aims to achieve greenhouse gas neutrality by 2045, with a focus on the industrial sector, including the vital glass industry. Comprising about 400 companies and 56,000 employees, the sector generated nearly €10 billion in turnover in 2021. The diverse product range, including container, flat, and special glasses, complicates decarbonization efforts. Currently producing 7.4 million tonnes of glass annually, the industry emits around 4 million tonnes of CO2, primarily from combustion and chemical reactions in the glass melt. While prior efficiency measures were taken, meeting 2045 targets requires adopting innovative and CO2-neutral melting methods, posing economic challenges and necessitating careful management of increased costs. The industry's successful decarbonization hinges on maintaining competitiveness amidst international competition and potential cost burdens.
The German glass industry was thoroughly examined for individual production sites, focusing on container glass, flat glass, and special and utility glass sectors. A transformation pathway model, utilizing production characteristics like furnace type, quantities, and energy consumption was used for the analysis. Three criteria influenced the selection of decarbonization measures: technology compatibility with glass products, availability of energy infrastructure for emission-free sources, and manufacturers' planned measures.
Four scenarios, including a reference scenario ("BAU") and extreme cases emphasizing electrification and hydrogen, were developed. The "hybrid scenario" represents a medium transformation path without specific energy carrier or technology focus. Changes in energy consumption, CO2 emissions, and costs were calculated for alternative pathways relative to the reference scenario.
The key findings of the analysis for the decarbonisation of the German glass industry are based on four scenarios: BAU (Business as Usual), Electrification, Hydrogen, and Hybrid. In 2045, the Hybrid scenario envisions replacing conventional melting tanks with hybrid, super hybrid, and all-electric furnaces, utilizing hydrogen as the gaseous energy carrier. This transition results in zero energy-related CO2 emissions. However, process-related CO2 emissions of 780,000 tonnes/year persist due to raw material constraints.
In order to convert the current plant fleet in the glass industry and to adapt inhouse and upstream energy infrastructures, investments of 3.2 - 5.6 billion Euro are required by 2045. The lower limit of 3.2 billion Euro reflects the investment requirement in the Hydrogen Scenario and is due to the significantly lower effort required to convert the glass furnaces and the necessary energy infrastructure by adapting the existing gas pipelines. However, implementation is fraught with uncertainties due to the difficulty of estimating nationwide hydrogen availability.The study anticipates economic, regulatory, and technical challenges. While Germany's Climate Protection Act aims for climate neutrality by 2045, complete decarbonization appears unfeasible, achieving only a 79% reduction. Creating supportive frameworks, addressing financial concerns, and expanding energy infrastructures are crucial for a successful industry transformation. In order to achieve the climate goals, suitable framework conditions should be created that enable transformation and prevent migration or plant closures.
The necessary energy infrastructures for the provision of CO2 neutral energy sources must be available and the energy sources available in sufficient quantities and at competitive prices. The decarbonisation of glass production will lead to an increase in specific production costs. Compensation for the additional operational costs through climate protection contracts (CCfD) and/or investment support for the implementation of decarbonisation measures are particularly suitable for cushioning the financial burdens on companies caused by the challenges of decarbonisation.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 3-022-23_Radgen_Pres.pdf

























