Search eceee proceedings

Designing green lead markets for decarbonising energy-intensive industries

Panel: 3. Drivers to change

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Anna Leipprand, Wuppertal Institute, Germany Thobias Sach, Guidehouse Germany GmbH, Germany Tobias Fleiter, Fraunhofer-Institut fuer System- und Innovationsforschung, Germany

Abstract

Industry, like other sectors, needs to bring its greenhouse gas emissions down to zero by mid-century. This requires a transformation that includes efficiency increases and demand reduction, but also new production technologies, in particular in energy-intensive industries like steel, cement and chemicals. The EU climate targets imply that all products sold and all materials used in Europe need to be climate-neutral by 2050. However, the costs of climate-friendly production in many cases are significantly higher than those of conventional production, and “green” materials are not yet competitive. Nor is their “green” characteristic (low/lower carbon footprint) necessarily visible to consumers or downstream businesses. So, while energy-intensive businesses and industry associations are bringing forward strategies for their climate-neutral future, actual investments are still to take up speed. This contribution analyses the role of green lead market policies in supporting the transformation of industry in Europe, and highlights some of the key challenges in designing them. The analyses are based on research done for the German Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action in the context of a stakeholder process on green lead markets in 2023.

Green lead market policies play a key role in the policy mix. They work through two mechanisms: First by steering existing demand for green products, and second by actively creating additional demand. Thus, they make future demand for green products more predictable and reliable and improve investment conditions for business actors. They support the effect of the EU ETS and help ensure a timely response of industry actors to the CO2 price signal, they reduce the need for subsidies, and they provide a starting point for international cooperation.

Agreeing on definitions for “green” products is a challenge. As a prerequisite for any measures, definitions need to be agreed on that clarify the requirements for materials to be eligible for the lead markets. These definitions need to rely on common standards or methodologies. Without these agreements, there would be a high risk of greenwashing and a lack of transparency and reliability. However, negotiating these definitions may be politically complex, since they eventually define both the overall level of ambition and the relative benefits different production processes will gain from the policies.

Policy instruments need to be designed carefully and with a view to international compatibility. Labels for basic materials products that make their climate performance visible enable consumers along the value chain to choose green materials. Public procurement can be a strong lever to create demand for green materials, if requirements are introduced to consider the climate performance in the purchases. Under the new EU Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation, minimum standards may be introduced for basic materials that will then apply to all products on the EU market. Also, general quota for green materials that apply also to private actors are an option to support demand. Policy efforts at national level need to take into consideration international implications. How do they relate to international initiatives for streamlining standards and methodologies? Can they inform and co-create policies at EU or international level, or will they be in opposition to them? The current efforts to build an international climate club with a focus on building and expanding markets for green industrial products highlight the potential for international cooperation on the topic. NOTE: eceee is not allowed to make this presentation public until later.

Downloads