Search eceee proceedings
Towards circular, efficient and focused policies to drive the EU industrial decarbonisation.
Panel: 3. Drivers to change
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Stéphane Arditi, EEB European Environmental Bureau, Belgium
Riccardo Nigro, European Environmental Bureau, Belgium
Christian Schaible, European Environmental Bureau, Belgium
Abstract
1.The shortfalls of EU policies aimed at decarbonising and depolluting the EU industry:
– They overlook the potential hidden behind demand side reduction, substitution, circular economy, and material and energy efficiency practices. All efforts assume an abundancy of feedstocks/materials, resulting in unrealistic targets.
– They lack focus and consequently support a very wide set of technologies, regardless of their impact on industrial decarbonisation, costs and timeframe.
– They tend to overlook the impact of industrial pollution on the environment and public health overall and from integrated manner. Current attention is almost only on CO2 emissions, disregarding potential cross media effects.
– They do not address the issue of drivers to set markets for sustainable products and to stimulate private investments.
– There is no clear definition of industrial transformation (e.g. key performance indicators to qualify sustainable production).
2.A limited approach carrying several limitations
– Making the industrial transition even more difficult than it already is; by disregarding the potential of circular and efficiency policies, pressure is unnecessarily exacerbated on production facilities (e.g. renewable hydrogen) instead of the energy system overall and conflicting uses. creating risks of strategic dependencies for key sectors.
– Decarbonisation of primary production shall not come to the expense of a wider zero-pollution ambition.
– The constant search for the “next big thing” that will fix it all, whereas the focus should be on massively deploying the best solutions, including non-technical ones, to provide the essential services to society.
– The use of limited public resources to support too many technologies or priority industry sectors disperses public funding in too many streams, making it less effective.
– The tendency to deal with “one crisis at a time” or one policy at a time, leading to inconsistent and less effective policymaking (e.g. IED-ETS divide).
– The lack of a business case for decarbonised products, resulting in few private investments and over-reliance on public support.
3.Going towards a “cascade of priorities”
According to a recent Agora Industrie & Systemiq study based on Germany, through circular economy practices cumulative GHG emissions can be reduced by 25% by 2045, transformation costs by 45% and energy consumption by 20%. Production of renewable electricity and renewable hydrogen can be reduced by 24%. Such figures suggest that all policies should be designed considering the following cascade of priorities:
Priority 1: introduce demand side optimisation and potential substitution in policies to reduce demand of carbon-intensive materials.
Priority 2: implement circular economy, energy and material efficiency strategies at sector level.
Actions in priorities 1 and 2 carry other positive impacts in terms of depollution and fossil feedstock displacement, while reducing the cost of the transition by reducing the needed investments in infrastructures (priority 3).
Priority 3: electrification of industrial processes and shifting towards non-combustion/material substitution practices.
Priority 4: use of carbon management strategies only for unavoidable emissions and permanent storage. The use of carbon as a feedstock, to be later emitted into the atmosphere, should never be supported by climate policies.
As overarching priority, the creation of markets for decarbonised products through product policies and green public procurement based on a robust carbon/pollution footprint methodology is needed to not rely only on public support.
This might lead to consider a specific issue: creating markets don't fit necessarily well with demand side reduction and substitution concepts. How to reconcile these two priorities? Could shifting from the “product decarbonisation” paradigm (e.g. steel, cement) to the “service decarbonisation” (e.g. mobility, dwelling) be a way to explore?
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 3-010-23_Arditi_Pres.pdf

























