Search eceee proceedings

Transformers – the forgotten opportunity: potentials and a tool to establish cost of ownership

Panel: 3. Drivers to change

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Michael Scholand, M2S2 Energy Ltd., United Kingdom

Abstract

Data analysis has shown that transformers cost a utility (or other business owning a transformer) several times more to operate than it is to purchase, however this high operating cost is not always apparent to the transformer procurement team. To the extent that these losses can be reduced in an economically justified way, future running costs will be lower, achieving a more economically optimal outcome over the lifetime of the transformer.

Transformers are often forgotten in energy efficiency policy measures since they are typically owned by electric utilities and thus are not part of energy production or end use. In many markets, distribution companies are allowed to pass the cost of their losses to their customers, which means there is no incentive to invest in energy efficiency. However, if energy-efficient transformers are selected, the United Nations Environment Programmes’ United for Efficiency initiative (UNEP U4E) estimates that annual electricity savings could reach 55 TWh in 2040, which is roughly the annual electricity consumption of Singapore, or the annual output of 25 large electric power plants. The savings would avoid 45 million metric tonnes of CO2 annually and save over US$7 billion on end-user electricity bills.

A procurement tool was developed for evaluating the efficiency of a transformer, enabling the selection of cost-optimised transformer designs. The IEC Technical Committee developed a “total cost of ownership” methodology which takes into account the value of future losses in the purchasing decision:

TCO = Purchase Price + ( A × (Watts of No-Load Losses))+(B × (Watts of Load Losses))

Where:

A-factor is the capitalisation of no-load losses, taking into account lifetime, discount rate and cost of electricity; the units are defined as the national currency per watt or kilowatt; and

B-factor is the capitalisation of load losses, taking into account lifetime, the discount rate, the cost of electricity and the loading on the transformer; the units are defined as the national currency per watt or kilowatt.

This methodology was published in the IEC’s international technical specification, IEC TS 60076-20:2017, Power Transformers – Part 20: Energy Efficiency on 30 January 2017, and a brief corrigendum issued in January 2018. The TCO approach is presented in Annex A of that document an informative Annex, titled “Capitalisation of losses”.

UNEP U4E wishes to encourage utilities and organisations that specify and procure transformers around the world to apply the TCO methodology when purchasing transformers, as it will result in reduced powerplant CO2 emissions while also enabling more economically optimised transformers.

In addition, U4E developed a second TCO methodology which elevates the cost of carbon in the calculation, and is offering this tool as a resource to help demonstrate the increased value of more energy-efficient transformers. The spreadsheet tool offers a second TCO methodology which reflects the value of carbon – i.e., a ton of CO2. U4E has developed a methodology by which this factor can be calculated for different transformer designs and introduced to the TCO calculation. This ensures that when looking at the total cost of ownership, utilities would not only capture the total direct cost of ownership from an equipment and losses perspective, but also the value of the CO2 emissions associated with those losses.

Irrespective of whichever method transformer procurement officers select, the consideration of future losses through the use of the TCO methodology when making a purchasing decision of a transformer is going to result in more economically rational outcomes which are better for the utility, the country and ultimately the planet.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-068-23_Scholand_Pres.pdf