Search eceee proceedings

Are emissions reduction and circularity goals compatible? The case of the Netherlands

Panel: 2. Sustainable industrial production systems

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Kira West, TNO Energy Transition Studies, The Netherlands Vinzenz Koning, Utrecht University Toon van Harmelen, TNO Gert Jan Kramer, Utrecht University André Faaij, TNO / Utrecht University

Abstract

Based on an expanded energy system model of the Netherlands, we examined the interaction between emissions reduction and circularity, material-energy tradeoffs, and feasibility of meeting both circularity and emission targets by 2050. We found that reducing non-biogenic direct material input (DMI) by up to about 60% does not increase the system cost in a low emissions scenario, but beyond 70%, system costs increase significantly. Beyond 83%, our model could not find a feasible solution to meet both targets. The use of scarce biomass resources is a particular point of tension between circularity and emissions reduction; in emissions-focused scenarios, applications with the potential for negative emissions tend to be prioritized, whereas material-focused scenarios tend to use it in the lowest-cost applications. Strategies like electrification combined with renewable electricity generation, energy storage and improved energy efficiency reduce both emissions and non-biogenic material use, and are attractive in both sets of scenarios.

Our analysis highlights the need to prioritize the use of scarce resources for the highest value applications, and to encourage further investment to bring down the costs of higher-R circularity strategies. Circular strategies can reduce emission reduction costs, but focusing on mass-based material indicators leads to higher-cost transition pathways, and incentivizes shifting negative environmental effects outside the scope of the metrics, or substituting unsustainable biomass use for unsustainable fossil fuel use. More and better data is needed on circularity and its costs, life cycle environmental impacts, and macroeconomic effects of changing energy and materials systems to improve policymaking in this area. Most importantly, our findings make clear the importance of considering energy and materials as part of the same system, to ensure that policy leads to improved environmental outcomes in multiple areas.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-007-25_West_Pres.pdf