Search eceee proceedings
Early Movers in the Green Transition: Risks, Benefits, and Strategic Implications
Panel: 4. Drivers to action – policies and market mechanisms
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Johan Rootzén, IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute, Sweden
Anna Hörbe Emanuelsson, Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden
Filip Johnsson, Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden
Abstract
Despite growing consensus on the need to address climate change, the transition to net-zero emissions remains a formidable challenge, especially in hard-to-abate industries such as steel, cement, and chemicals. These sectors are characterized by high capital intensity, global supply chains, and historically low R&D spending. While low-carbon technologies are emerging, large-scale deployment is lagging behind. Meanwhile, geopolitical tensions, economic slowdowns, and rising protectionism (e.g. new tariffs, uncertainty around CBAM, proposed changes to the EU ETS) are leading some political actors to question the pace and scope of the EU’s climate policies. These uncertainties create a high-risk environment for actors choosing to lead in the green transition.
This study draws on insights from environmental economics and sustainability transitions research to analyse how such structural and institutional factors shape the feasibility of early industrial action. Empirically, the analysis is based on semi-structured interviews and stakeholder workshops with key actors across the value chain. These engagements identify perceived barriers to the transition and capture perspectives on the extent to which existing policy instruments are capable of addressing them.
Key barriers include lengthy permitting processes, competing land uses, difficulties in attracting skilled labour, and the need to build liveable communities in emerging industrial regions. Industrial expansion requires not only capital investment, but also housing, social services, transport infrastructure, and cultural amenities, raising important questions about how costs and risks should be shared between firms, municipalities, and the state.
EU climate policy, particularly the EU ETS, constitutes the backbone of Europe’s industrial transition. However, public support at both national and EU levels remains critical to bridge the “valley of death” for large-scale decarbonisation projects. At the same time, policies targeting demand-side transformation, such as green public procurement, product standards, and circular material strategies, are still under development but represent essential complements to supply-side measures.
Sweden possesses several structural strengths: competitive and largely fossil-free electricity supply, rich biomass resources, strong industrial networks (e.g. high-strength steel and vehicle manufacturing), relatively strong unions, and a well-functioning welfare system. Yet important uncertainties remain. These include the credibility of medium- and long-term policy commitments, the timely expansion of renewable electricity supply, and the management of distributional impacts of structural change. Ensuring that workers and communities can access affordable low-carbon alternatives, for example electric vehicles and reliable charging infrastructure, is central to maintaining political legitimacy.
Looking ahead, the transition raises broader strategic questions. How can green industrial ambitions be balanced with rising defence spending and other political priorities? What constitutes a balanced policy mix that supports both pioneers and laggards? How can policies better incentivise demand-side measures while simultaneously creating lead markets for net-zero basic materials? And how can learning be institutionalised so that valuable experience is retained even when projects do not reach full implementation?
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 4-038-25_Rootzeen_Pres.pdf

























