Search eceee proceedings
Implementation proposals advance strategies for lead markets
Panel: 4. Drivers to action – policies and market mechanisms
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Meta Thurid Lotz, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Simon Bussmann, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Thobias Sach, Guidehouse, Germany
Tobias Fleiter, Fraunhofer Institute of Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Jannis Speckmann, Guidehouse, Germany
Abstract
Green lead markets can support the policy mix for a competitive and climate-neutral industry by creating demand for climate-friendly products - thus, reducing reliance on subsidies, increasing planning security and creating investment incentives. While strategies, such as the EU’s Clean Industrial Deal, highlight the importance of such markets, the practical implementation remains vague. This study aims to (partially) close this gap by analyzing selected policy design parameters and developing proposals for green lead markets targeting cement, steel, and ethylene.
The analysis follows four steps: First, the value chains are examined to identify suitable stages and stakeholders for intervention. Second, the required level of ambition is defined by contrasting criteria for climate-friendly basic materials with required production process switches. Third, a timeline is developed for green lead markets aligned with a climate-neutrality scenario. Finally, these insights are compared against potential instruments, namely labelling, minimum standards, public procurement, and market-based ramp-up. Labelling corrects a key market failure by allowing consumers to distinguish between climate-friendly and conventional basic materials. Proactively defined minimum requirements with increasing ambition can enable transformation of specific product groups. Public procurement is suitable for establishing initial markets and niches due to its signaling effect, but it can also be significant beyond that. In contrast, a market-based ramp-up mechanism does not only address limited market shares but covers (as far as possible) the entire market.
The findings highlight that designing green lead markets is complex and requires a material-specific approach due to the distinct characteristics of each value chain. For cement, we propose binding requirements for public construction projects, based on an industry label, given the sector's homogeneous value chain and the necessity of deploying carbon capture technologies. It remains open how private demand can be stimulated. For steel, we suggest a European market-based ramp-up mechanism obliging distributors and differentiating high and construction-grade steel, to address varying quality requirements and incentivize gradual improvements. Due to the necessary lead time, we suggest supporting short-term instruments for particularly relevant end products made from steel, such as minimum content requirements for climate-friendly steel in the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation or public pilots. In the case of ethylene, ambitious minimum content requirements seem the most viable option to incentivize novel processes and fossil-free feedstocks. For this purpose, we propose expanding the minimum content requirements for packaging defined in the Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation to recognize climate-friendly ethylene. It remains unclear how other products made from ethylene can be ad-dressed.
While the results focus on Germany, the proposals are advancing current strategies for green lead markets by addressing their practical implementation for basic materials and serve as foundation for policy discussions within the EU. This paves the way for early adoption of climate-friendly production processes and the establishment of a market for climate-friendly basic materials, which could prove to be a competitive advantage in the long term.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 4-013-25_Lotz_Pres.pdf

























