Search eceee proceedings

Industrial Hydrogen Demand and the Role of Imports, Carbon Pricing, and CBAM in Germany

Panel: 4. Drivers to action – policies and market mechanisms

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Lin Zheng, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany Johannes Eckstein, Fraunhofer Institute for System and Innovation Research, Germany

Abstract

Hydrogen is a key option for decarbonizing hard-to-abate sectors, such as steel and chemicals. Yet, its economic feasibility is uncertain without a hydrogen market. This study applies a novel approach to derive industrial hydrogen demand curves for Germany, and uses 12 scenarios (3 groups, with 4 price projections each) to analyze the impact of energy and carbon prices on technology diffusion and hydrogen demand. Moreover, industrial relocation and the effect of Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) are evaluated by comparing the 3 groups: (i) only local production, (ii) imports of end-products as an alternative, and (iii) imports combined with CBAM. Specifically, industrial relocation is assessed by comparing import scenarios with those restricted to local production.

To determine consumers’ willingness-to-pay (WTP, or acceptable hydrogen price) for hydrogen, the applied approach explicitly accounts for the costs of competing technologies, which are primarily based on coal and natural gas in investigated industries, and the corresponding hydrogen demands are defined by the hydrogen consumption in plants substituting the correlating production units.

Overall, the derived hydrogen demand curves for both analyzed years (2030 and 2050) indicate that higher energy and carbon prices raise WTP and hydrogen demand, shifting the demand curves upward across all scenarios, while the drivers of hydrogen demand differ across scenario groups. Among the three investigated industries, the primary steel industry emerges as the largest hydrogen consumer, while the methanol industry shows limited to no hydrogen demand due to low WTP. Without import, the acceptable prices are the highest, due to the restricted international competition. In these scenarios without import, fuel prices are the dominating factor of the WTP for hydrogen, as they also dominate the economics of non-hydrogen-based low-carbon alternatives. Allowing imports as an additional alternative makes hydrogen options less economically viable and consequently lowers the demand, especially by 2030. Nevertheless, applying CBAM increases WTP slightly and narrows the gap with scenarios without imports.

By 2030, in scenarios without imports, fuel prices are the dominant determinant of WTP for hydrogen. In contrast, in scenarios that allow imports, carbon prices exert a stronger influence by determining the timeline for domestic low-carbon technologies to become cost-competitive, particularly for natural gas-based direct reduced iron. Even with CBAM in place, domestic low-carbon production generally remains more expensive than imported products, limiting early hydrogen deployment and increasing relocation risks.

By 2050, in scenarios with imports but without CBAM, higher carbon prices emerge as the key enabler of hydrogen deployment. When CBAM is introduced and fully phased in, it raises import prices, which often serve as a competing reference for hydrogen-based production, thereby increasing WTP and demand and shifting the demand curves upward. Notably, under high fuel price projections, CBAM can stimulate more hydrogen demand in the ammonia industry at medium to low hydrogen price levels than in scenarios without import.

The results also disclose potential industrial transitions without a hydrogen market. As imports outbid local production with carbon capture, allowing imports would raise relocation risks, particularly in the chemical sector, where carbon capture is the only alternative to hydrogen or imports. While scenarios without imports result in the highest WTP, they do not reflect real-world market dynamics with international trade and competition. CBAM helps accelerate the timeline of local low-carbon production becoming cost-competitive with imports, strengthening the long-term economic feasibility of hydrogen. However, additional short-term support remains crucial until CBAM is fully phased in, to mitigate relocation risks and enable early hydrogen market establishment.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 4-009-25_Zheng_Pres.pdf