Search eceee proceedings

Equity, innovation and the role of local governments: the case of Rural Electrification in France

Panel: Panel 3: Market Transformation: Innovation, Development and Dissemination

Author:
Michel Colombier, International Conseil Energie, France

Abstract

Rural electrification mechanisms were first established in France for equity and local development purposes. Based on a large mobilisation of local rural governments, and a price equalisation allowed by redistribution from urban areas to the rural communities, well adapted when electricity was planned for specific, non competitive uses (with effective, direct externalities on local development), this policy has become today a strong barrier to the entry of innovative solutions (energy efficient equipment, different kinds of fuels, renewable energies) on a market of 18 million people.

This results in a very restrictive impact on the dynamics of technological innovation, a strong inhibition of the promotion of local resources, and a growing economic cost for the overall society (lo9 dollars a year for grid development).

The study focuses on the relationships between mstitutional mechanisms and the selection of techniques. The diversification of technological paths appears to be blocked by the automatic nature of funding in favour of the grid, which contrasts with the skimpy and site-specific support given to alternative solutions. Local governments remain formally in charge of rural electrification, but have no effective control over the electricity market and demand side efficiency.

If the current institutional kangements are revealed obsolete, the initial motivations of local.governments ~111 still be legitimate. A ?new deal? is proposed where local governments recover their effective role of planning and promoting policies, by considering the concept of ?equity of access to a range of energy services? instead of ?to a final energy delivery?.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper