Search eceee proceedings

Rhetoric and reality in energy efficiency policy

Panel: Panel 1: Policy (incentives, normative measures, policy mixes to achive CO_2 reduction)

Author:
Tina Fawcett, Environmental Change Unit, University of Oxford

Abstract

Any European strategy which is serious about meeting Kyoto targets needs an underpinning, strong regulatory framework. However, the EU is currently looking towards negotiated agreements rather than mandatory standards for appliances, and the timetable for previously agreed legislation is slipping. Without concerted EU action, nation states are unlikely to meet their Kyoto targets. While the rhetoric speaks of the need to take strong and effective policy action, the reality may be a disappointing mix of compromise and delay which fails to deliver significant savings.

Detailed policies to access savings of over two million tonnes of carbon (2MtC) by 2010 have been identified for UK lights and appliances. In order to achieve these savings, strong common and co-ordinated policies and measures at a European level are required, this means a systematic programme of European legislation including minimum standards of efficiency for a number of products. These savings constitute almost 8% of the savings needed to meet the UK government’s 20% carbon reduction target, and can be achieved at no net cost to the consumer. The strategy also incorporates equity considerations - low income households will not be disadvantaged. UK action alone cannot achieve anything approaching the same level of savings, nor can EU action which relies heavily on negotiated agreements with manufacturers, as shown by the analysis presented.

In addition, the cost of achieving savings with the EU and member states working together is far lower than other options. This is illustrated by the UK case study.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper