Search eceee proceedings

Socio-economic barriers and success factors in the development of low energy consumption housing. A comparative study in three European countries

Panel: Panel 1. The foundations of future energy policies: Initiating change and breaking walls

Authors:
Véronique Beillan, EDF Recherche & Développement, ICAME Department, France
Emmanuelle Cayre, EDF Recherche & Développement, ENERBAT Department, France
Aurélie Goater, Alphéeis – Energy & Environment Consulting, France
Pia Laborgne, EIFERifer, Germany
Andreas Huber, EIFERifer, Germany
Régine Trotignon, ADEME, France
Ulrich Rochard, Ebök, Germany
André Pouget, POUGET Consultants, France
Dusan Novakov, Novasystem En+, Switzerland

Abstract

This study, conducted in 2007-2008, analyses the key factors for allowing the offer of low energy buildings to meet the demand of the households and making low energy consumption operations succeed. It applies a qualitative (on-site survey of several houses) as well as a European comparative approach.

Three countries with different levels of development of energy efficient buildings have been chosen: Germany, Switzerland and France. In each country several new single houses with a high-energy performance level - compared to the current regulatory level - have been selected. Around forty interviews have been conducted with inhabitants of the single-family house sector where the final users are also the decision-makers, and with professionals involved in the building of these low energy houses. Main results show the role of meso actors like professionals, association and local communities and the importance of regulations and constructions standards to be taken into account in future policies.

Beforehand, an historical analysis in the three countries has enabled us to identify the main facts occurring these thirty last years and their effect on the implementation of low energy buildings: major societal events like the oil crisis, the evolution of the legislation and the regulation, governments’ incentives, R&D progress, voluntary initiatives of market players. To provide a reliable comparative analysis, a detailed study has also been conducted on the three energy efficient building labels existing in the selected countries. This analysis showed in which point a comparison based only on a first reading of the objectives of energy consumptions to be reached doesn’t correspond to the reality of the aimed performances: although expressed in kWh/m², the requirements do not recover the same domain and are not calculated with equivalent hypotheses.

This study has been carried out in a framework of a partnership between energy providers, public and private energy and environmental experts in the three EU countries.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper