Search eceee proceedings

What can we learn from tradable green certificate markets for trading white certificates?

Panel: Panel 2. Policy implementation: learning from the past, improving the future

Authors:
Reinhard Haas, Institute for Power Systems and Energy Economics, Energy Economics Group (EEG), Austria
Nanna N. Sagbauer, Institute for Power Systems and Energy Economics, Energy Economics Group (EEG), Austria
Gustav Resch, Institute for Power Systems and Energy Economics, Energy Economics Group (EEG), Austria

Abstract

With respect to trading energy related certificates in recent years in EU countries two different categories were introduced or discussed: Tradable Green Certificates (TGC) for electricity from Renewable Energy Sources (RES), CO2 emission certificates, and Tradable White Certificates (TWC) for Demand-Side energy Conservation measures (DSC).

The objective of this paper is to derive lessons learned from TGC markets for possible TWC markets. The method of approach applied is based on cost-resource curves in a dynamic framework. It is applied to the development of RES and DSC markets without and with certificate trade. Of core relevance is the focus on providing public money only for the difference between the BAU scenario and the certificate trade scenario.

The major result is that there are the following potential backlashes regarding high costs for the public arising from certificate trade for meeting the quota: (i) Free riders (customers who would have installed a RES-E system or a DSC measure also without a certificate); (ii) Non-liquid markets, which lead to a lack of competition, high rates-of-return and to short depreciation times; (iii) the penalties for not meeting the quota are to low.

The major conclusions are that the following requirements have to be fulfilled in every trading system: (i) avoid free riders and adverse selection, (ii) implement high penalties, (iii) ensure sufficiently large markets.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper

Presentation

Download this presentation as pdf: Presentation