Search eceee proceedings

Evaluation of the economic and ecological effects of the French ‘bonus malus’

Panel: Panel 2. Policy implementation: learning from the past, improving the future

Authors:
Gaël Callonnec, ADEME
Isabelle Sannié, ADEME

Abstract

The French Agency for Environment and Energy Management (ADEME) has undertaken to evaluate the efficiency of a possible extension of the “Bonus malus” system, applied to sales of automobiles, to several other classes of products.

Equipment that consumes relatively little power, or goods that are relatively non-polluting, could benefit from a subsidy, while energy-intensive and/or highly polluting products could be taxed in proportion to their energy efficiency or degree of harmfulness.

As the government wants to keep the global tax rate constant, bonuses would have to be strictly financed by income from penalties. To establish a scale that will produce a balanced budget, it is necessary to estimate accurately the changes in market share caused by the measure, which may be significant. For example, the market share of vehicles of classes A and B has increased from 20.4% to 31% in only three months.

Two models were used to assess the economic and ecological effects of bonus malus. One relies on a representation of curves of aggregated demand in a situation of perfect competition. Another, inspired by the NPV (Net Present Value) theory, assumes that consumers maximize their profits. The theoretical assumptions, benefits and limitations of each model are presented.

The models provide relatively homogeneous results, except when the price gaps between different classes of goods are too narrow. In such a case, an important threshold effect can occur.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper

Presentation

Download this presentation as pdf: Presentation