Search eceee proceedings

The life cycle race – silver and bronze go to … passive house and low energy house

Panel: Panel 7. Innovative buildings technologies

Author:
Andreas Hermelink, ECOFYS Germany GmbH, Germany

Abstract

In 2000 the world's first multi-story passive houses with 23 and 17 apartments for tenants have been erected in Kassel, Germany. The building with 23 apartments has been chosen for in-depth analyses of various kinds.

In-depth environmental life-cycle assessments (LCA) for the passive house and its imaginary low-energy counterpart including all typical technical equipment have been made, covering a period of 80 years. Real household energy consumption data (DHW, space heat, electricity) have been analysed for the first six years of operation and fed into the LCA, too.

Based on this , two paths have been elaborated:

  • Per capita CO 2 emissions have been measured against the "sustainable personal carbon allowance" for 2050, which seems to be reasonable compared to a building's lifetime.
  • For the first time, life-cycle cost-efficiency tests, originally developed for DSM programs have been transferred to the economic comparison between passive and low energy houses. The "participant test" (residents' perspective) and the "societal test" (society's perspective) were selected. In the societal test, even the external costs of CO 2 and SO 2 from manufacturing are accounted for. For both tests sensitivity analyses for several parameters have been conducted.

The analyzed passive house still needs some easy-to-do optimization to outpace its low-energy challenger in all investigated environmental categories. Both cost-efficiency tests see the passive house as the winner of most sensitivity cases. The most surprising result, however, is, that even in this favourable case of "only few m 2 floor area per cap in a passive house" the CO 2 emissions per cap still exceed what may be regarded as a sustainable level.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper

Presentation

Download this presentation as pdf: Presentation