Search eceee proceedings

Standardisation of practices and representations of users in the ecodesign Directive

Panel: Panel 8. Dynamics of consumption

Authors:
Nicolas Prignot, Centre for Studies on Sustainable Development - Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium
Grégoire Wallenborn, Centre for Studies on Sustainable Development - Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium

Abstract

Our project, ISEU (Integration of Standards, Ecodesign and Users in energy-using products ), is among other concerned with the implementation of the ‘ecodesign Directive’ on energy-using products (EuPs). The preparatory studies of this Directive make recommendations on implementing measures, and are discussed in expert meetings and in consultation forums, where industries, public authorities and NGOs are represented.

Each preparatory study follows a common methodology. We have analysed in detail the part concerning “consumer behaviour and infrastructure” for four categories of products: heating regulation, domestic lighting, computers and washing machines. This analysis reveals different interesting points. Each studied product category discloses a singular technological dynamics and a different figure of users. In the case of washing machines, the observation of a divergence between real uses and standards has led to the proposition of new standards more in phase with current practices. To enforce the ban of incandescent bulbs, users are described both as reluctant and potentially aware of the need of recycling the CFL’s. Computers are evolving very fast, and so are their related practices; this questions the possibility to reach an agreement about a lasting energy standard for computers. In the case of heating, users are poorly considered to the extent that the control of the system is delegated to electronic devices.

The modelling of the use phase induces biases in the standardisation of energy efficiency of appliances. Standard tests for the energy labelling are conceived on the basis of an average use, sometimes far away from real behaviours and the diversity of practices. As in the case of washing machines, it can be argued that the labelling scheme and standards have and will transform the appliances available on the market in a direction possibly opposed to practices’ evolution.

Paper

Download this paper as pdf: Paper

Presentation

Download this presentation as pdf: Presentation