Search eceee proceedings
Do energy labels have the capacity to mislead?
Panel: 7. Monitoring and evaluation
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Author:
Bruce Young, Building Research Establishment (BRE), United Kingdom
Abstract
A purchaser naturally expects the energy performance of an "A" labelled product to be better than a "B", and so on down the scale. The energy efficiency index that underlies the rating scale has been carefully designed to ensure that, but only under specific assumptions about installation conditions and method of use. For some products – notably heating plant – energy performance varies substantially under differing load conditions. For example, model X may be better than model Y under full load but Y is better than X under low load. The energy efficiency index might have been designed with this possibility in mind, calling for tests at two or more load conditions and combining the results in some way to produce the single-number index that determines the A to G rating. It is the combination process that is the weak step here, because both X and Y may achieve the same rating on the label but X would be better than Y if installed in a building with high loads and Y would be better than X with low loads. This presents a problem for an energy labelling scheme in which the installation conditions are not known at the time the energy rating is calculated. Conditions can, of course, be assumed in the energy calculation but there is no prospect of changing the result to represent actual conditions without another calculation using real building data. It could turn out that of two products X and Y, having energy ratings A and B respectively, X is not the better choice. Should we therefore abandon the energy labelling of products where the labelling method is too simplistic, inevitably so because building characteristics strongly affect performance but are not known at the time of labelling? What other products, apart from heat generators, might be subject to similar methodological weaknesses? Or are there other solutions that can overcome the difficulty and produce more reliable guidance?
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 7-254_Young_po.pdf
Download this paper as pdf: 7-254_Young.pdf










