Search eceee proceedings

Ex-post evaluation of a residential energy efficiency policy measure using empirical data

Panel: 7. Monitoring and evaluation 

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Author:
Fionn Rogan , University College Cork, Ireland Brian O Gallachoir, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University College Cork, Ireland, Ireland

Abstract

Between 1990 and 2008, Ireland’s total final consumption in the residential sector grew by 31.5%, considerably higher growth than most other developed countries in the EU15 for the same period. Historically, the housing stock in Ireland has been both small compared to the total population and very energy-inefficient. From 1990 to 2008, Ireland experienced an 86% increase in housing numbers and in 2002, a new set of building regulations was introduced, which were designed to achieve a 20% reduction in dwelling energy consumption, compared to the previous regulations. Enforcement of the new regulations, while officially delegated to local authorities, was in practice, largely self-regulated. To conduct an ex-post evaluation on the impact of the 2002 building regulations on dwelling energy consumption, a database of yearly-metered-consumption for all gas connected dwellings between 1990 and 2008 was interrogated. The metered consumption data was regionally climate-corrected using annual degree-day data. Two sub-groups of dwellings were chosen: those built to 2002 regulations and those built to the previous regulations. Adjustments for changing floor size were made from a planning permissions database; however, adjustments for different household income were not made. Following appropriate outlier filtering, the two sub-groups were verified to be normally distributed. Using a two-sample t-test, an initial analysis revealed an 11% reduction in average dwelling energy consumption, compared to an energy savings target of 20%. This initial assessment was for three-bedroom, semi-detached dwellings in Dublin only; further analysis for all regions and dwelling types is in progress. There is also scope determining the relative contribution of building regulation non-compliance and the rebound effect. The analysis will be used to inform policy’s role in enforcement of building regulations and will also be used to model the future impact of more stringent building regulations.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 7-520_Rogan.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-520_Rogan_pre.pdf