Search eceee proceedings
There are people in the house! How the results of purely technical analysis of residential energy consumption are misleading for energy policies
Panel: 7. Monitoring and evaluation
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Author:
Emmanuelle Cayre, EDF R&D, France
Benoit Allibe, CIRED, Campus du Jardin Tropical, France
Marie-Hélène Laurent, EDF-R&D, ENERBAT Dpt., France
Dominique Osso, EDF-R&D, ENERBAT Dpt., France
Abstract
In France, bottom-up models of national space heating energy consumption aiming at orienting energy policies are mostly based on the same basic framework modelling, derived from the 1988 French thermal regulation, like this used for the Energy Performance Certificate (EPC). However, empirical evidence suggests significant differences between observed consumptions and those calculated with such a basic model like EPC. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the factors that could explain these differences and especially the role of the daily management of space heating (temperature and ventilation rate) by occupants, which is standardised in this basic model. Based on an analysis of time-series (1998-2005) and cross-sectional data (2009 survey), we quantified the impact of this daily behaviour on energy consumption and implemented this “behavioural factor” in the EPC basic model. Our results suggest that this factor depends on the theoretical budget share of space heating, calculated as the income share dedicated to the theoretical space heating bill. Thus, this factor makes it possible to depict rebound effect as well as price and income elasticities. It is worth noting that the impact of this factor on energy consumption is comparable to the impact of average technical improvements. As our focus is on long-term modelling, implications for long-term policy decisions have been studied. Thus, simulations of French residential space heating demand have been carried out over the 2010-2030 period using 2 variants of the EPC basic model. Results show that standard calculations (basic model), even if calibrated, strongly overestimate space heating consumption in older housing as well as their energy savings potential. Therefore, using evaluations based on standard calculations that neglect behaviours may lead to a significant overestimation of the energy savings achievable in the residential sector.
Downloads
Download this paper as pdf: 7-277_Cayre.pdf
Download this presentation as pdf: 7-277_Cayre_pre.pdf










