Search eceee proceedings

Constructed logics: social ideals, residential design and energy use

Panel: 8. Dynamics of consumption 

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Author:
Nicole Biggart, UC Davis Grad School of Management, USA Loren Lutzenhiser, Urban Studies and Planning, USA

Abstract

This research explores the way in which ideologies and worldviews lead actors to make and justify residential choices with attendant energy use and conservation consequences. Actors are drawn to building designs that concretize what for them are appealing quality of life ideologies. A fieldwork study and archival research led us to identify two dimensions along which actors differ in how they frame choices of home design and related energy-using residential technologies. We develop a two-dimensional conceptual scheme that helps to understand how ideas and values come to be expressed in particular decisions and practices with material outcomes. This research is conducted from an economic sociology perspective and assumes that while actors may give primacy to price as a determinant of choice, we do not assume this. We found that the social status-conferring attributes of a house are a critical factor in choice. A house is the largest consumption purchase for most people, but a house’s meaning goes beyond economics. A house’s design, whether carefully considered or left to happenstance, is an expression of aesthetics, taste, values, status, and personal identity. Based on fieldwork and archival research, we argue that housing choice is inextricably bound up with ideas of “the good life” and that residential energy use is greatly affected by this conceptualization.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 8-158_Biggart.pdf