Search eceee proceedings

Somewhere in between a ‘Comedy of errors’ and a ‘As you like it’?: A brief history of Britain’s ‘Green Deal’ so far

Panel: 1. Foundations of future energy policy

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Pedro Guertler, enfinn, United Kingdom
Sarah Royston, Association for the Conservation of Energy, United Kingdom
David Robson, Managing Director, Instagroup; Green Deal Finance Company Steering Committee, United Kingdom

Abstract

The Green Deal finance mechanism is designed to enable households and small businesses to install energy efficiency improvements at no up-front cost. The capital is granted so long as the repayments (for which the utility bill payer, not the building owner, is liable) do not exceed the value of the predicted energy savings. Completely new to any European country, it has been described as a “no-brainer”, a “game-changer”, a “massive economic and job opportunity which could help Britain’s economy turn the corner” and “the biggest home energy efficiency drive since the Second World War” (Secretary of State Chris Huhne, 2010-2011; Minister of State Greg Barker, 2011).

The Green Deal was launched on October 1, 2012 – and despite it being the Government’s flagship green policy, the responsible Department of Energy and Climate Change did not even issue a press release on that day. What happened? This small incident is just the tip of an iceberg of a sometimes tumultuous but always fascinating process of policy development. From its inception as a political manifesto commitment in early 2010, the Green Deal’s evolution has seen ministers announcing very high ambitions, contrasted with official predictions of very low take-up; press coverage ranging from good to bad to ugly; and stakeholders (often simultaneously) alienated and more heavily engaged than ever before: all framed by the still considerable uncertainty about this new policy mechanism.

The dichotomies alluded to above provide the focal point and aim for this paper: to convey a multi-faceted history of the still young Green Deal. The paper will review its intellectual, political, cultural (media), and stakeholder (involvement) history – by drawing on policy papers, speeches, press articles, meeting notes and stakeholders themselves – to paint a vivid picture of policy development in practice and draw out conclusions for policy-makers and others who might consider embarking into similarly uncharted policy waters.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-306-13_Guertler_pre.pdf

Download this paper as pdf: 1-306-13_Guertler.pdf