Search eceee proceedings

Towards a better understanding of local reorganization processes – empirical findings from two case studies

Panel: 1. Foundations of future energy policy

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Andreas Huber, Eifer - European Institute for Energy Research, Germany
Jens Koehrsen, Oldenburg University, Germany
Jannika Mattes, Oldenburg University, Germany

Abstract

Both currently dominant sustainability transition theories, the Multi-Level-Perspective and the Technological Innovation Systems approach, have been criticized for their insufficient conceptualization of local transformation processes. This partial blindness is highly surprising from the background of evidently strong local development differences. In this paper, we aim to contribute to a more nuanced understanding of local energy-related reorganization processes (comprising both, energy generation and demand), presenting results from case studies on two cities in Germany, Emden and Bottrop. Borrowing freely from ideas of the regional innovation systems (RIS) approach, we analyse various “institutional spheres” (science, local politics, city administration, industry, banking, intermediaries and civil society) and the ongoing change processes arising from their interaction. Conceptually, we distinguish between first order and second order innovation. First order innovation refers to small scale, piecemeal adaptations (e.g. singular experimentations by a particular actor) while second order innovation points at systemic reconfigurations at the level of the actor system. Drawing on institutionalist thinking, we examine these more encompassing accommodation processes along four analytical dimensions: a strategic dimension referring to changes on the level of power constellations; a normative dimension looking at the reshaping of definitions of appropriate behaviour; a procedural dimension analyzing refined patterns of interaction and organization; and a cognitive dimension examining the redefinition of shared perceptions of problems and solutions and the creation of new knowledge. Evidence for second order changes on all four analytical dimensions indicates a growing institutionalization of Local Energy Transition Systems in both cities. This finding raises questions on the relationship between first and second order innovation.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 1-457-13_Huber.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-457-13_Huber_pre.pdf