Search eceee proceedings
The tragedy of energy efficiency. An interdisciplinary analysis of rebound effects
Panel: 1. Foundations of future energy policy
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Author:
Grégoire Wallenborn, IGEAT, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium
Abstract
Energy efficiency improvements are generally seen as the most cost-efficient and effective strategies to achieve a rapid transition to a more sustainable society. However, so-called rebound effects arise when energy users or producers change their behaviour after an efficiency improvement has taken place so that they actually consume more energy related to services or commodities than expected. This may significantly reduce the expected benefits of efficiency improvements. The magnitude of rebound effects, particularly at the whole economy level, is however controversial.
I suggest that controversies about rebound effects come from the fact that they can arise at different scales of time and space, and that each discipline captures some rebound mechanisms as they frame differently their objects of inquiry. In order to analyse the different rebound mechanisms, I consider four disciplinary framings: ecology, engineering, (neoclassical) economics and sociology (of practices). In each discipline I identify different kinds of rebounds. I show that in general they combine the improvement of energy and time efficiencies. Energy efficiency is linked to the minimisation of energy consumption (or entropy) and time efficiency amounts to mechanisms of maximisation (of power or profit) or multiplication (of machines or practices). I conclude that the combination of energy and time efficiency probably leads to backfire at long-term. The exploration through disciplines displays also the importance of infrastructure and system evolution in the shaping of rebound effects. I suggest that besides energy, power is an issue in itself that must be addressed if energy reduction is thought to be a premier objective.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-355-15_Wallenborn_pre.pdf
Download this paper as pdf: 1-355-15_Wallenborn.pdf
Panels of
1. Foundations of future energy policy
2. Energy efficiency policies – how do we get it right?
4. Mobility, transport, and smart and sustainable cities
5. Energy use in buildings: projects, technologies and innovation
6. Policies and programmes towards a zero-energy building stock
7. Appliances, product policy and the ICT supply chain
8. Monitoring and evaluation: building confidence and enhancing practices










