Search eceee proceedings

Real-time, evidence-based policy making – critical for decisions on rapidly evolving technologies

Panel: 7. Appliances, product policy and the ICT supply chain

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Peter Bennich, CLASP, United Kingdom
Michael Scholand, CLASP European Programme, Brussels
Bram Soenen, Belgian Ministry for Health, Food Chain Safety and Environment, Belgium
Nils Borg, eceee, Sweden
Michael Scholand, CLASP, United Kingdom

Abstract

Phasing out incandescent lamps has been widely acknowledged as one of the most cost-effective, surest ways to achieve rapid energy savings in mature and emerging markets. In 2009, Europe adopted an ecodesign policy measure on non-directional lighting to phase out incandescent lamps over a six year period. This policy measure established a gradual market transition toward higher efficiency lamps, with the final stage of this regulation currently scheduled to take effect in September 2016. That final stage would remove mains-voltage halogen lamps from the European market, promoting more efficient technologies. But this adopted measure has concerned some industry stakeholders who are calling for a delay or abolishment of the regulatory level. Some governments, citing consumer concerns, have supported this call for a delay as well. DG Energy commissioned a review study on the feasibility of Stage 6 that was published in mid-2013. This study included a projection of LED replacement lamp price and performance based on the best information available at that time. But in the last year, innovation in LED products has far exceeded expectations, and performance levels anticipated in 2018 to 2020 are being observed today in 2014 – still two years before the effective date of Stage 6. In this context, it became clear that in order for policy makers make an informed decision, some new evidence would be needed. Thus, the authors designed and conducted a testing study, purchasing 160 clear LED replacement lamps from vendors across Europe and tested them in an accredited lighting laboratory. This evidence base of current products on the market will help inform policy makers, enabling them to decide whether to keep, delay or abolish Stage 6. This case study for lighting shows how evidence based information is needed in times of quick technical and market developments. It highlights the need for resources and capacity within governments to act quickly in response to such developments. It also illustrates how quickly technical and market forecasts may become outdated. Significant energy saving opportunities may be lost if policy making is based on outdated forecasts.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-337-15_Bennich_pre.pdf

Download this paper as pdf: 7-337-15_Bennich-rev.pdf