Search eceee proceedings
A case study of deep retrofit in mixed tenure (rented and owned) UK social apartment blocks
Panel: 6. Buildings policies, directives and programmes
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Susan Bright, University of Oxford
New College, United Kingdom
David Weatherall, Energy Saving Trust, United Kingdom
Roxana Willis, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
Abstract
Article 19 of the Energy Efficiency Directive requires EU member states to address split incentives for energy efficiency between the multiple owners of buildings. Levels of energy refurbishment in apartment blocks are lower than in single-family houses. The way in which multi-family dwellings are owned and buildings are managed (the "governance arrangements") vary significantly between EU member states. These governance arrangements have a direct impact on what is possible in terms of energy retrofit but the complexity and specialist nature of the legal issues means they are under-researched. The current authors have demonstrated elsewhere how governance arrangements of apartments blocks in England and in Scotland impact on energy efficiency retrofit.
This paper reports on a detailed case study of a major refurbishment of 5 tower blocks owned by Oxford City Council (OCC), to include upgrades to reach high energy standards. Opposition to OCC’s plans to pass a share of the retrofit costs to individuals who own (rather than rent) flats has received national press attention.
The paper presents findings on the following key issues:
i) the nature of the refurbishment works;
ii) how the tenure mix impacts on the block owner’s decision to refurbish;
iii) How governance arrangements (determined by national law) affect the financing and delivery of retrofit:
a) OCC’s rights to recover costs from individual flat owners;
b) the effectiveness of required consultation processes between OCC and flat owners;
iv) how OCC and flat owners perceive the benefits of the upgrade and the legal arrangements.
The paper concludes a) with lessons for future retrofit projects, and b) argues that more legal analysis and empirical research is needed to understand and address governance barriers to energy efficiency in Europe's apartment blocks.
Downloads
Download this paper as pdf: 6-283-17_Bright.pdf
Download this presentation as pdf: 6-283-17_Bright_presentation.pdf
Panels of
1. Foundations of future energy policy
2. Policy: governance, design, implementation and evaluation challenges
4. Mobility, transport, and smart and sustainable cities
5. Buildings and construction technologies and systems
6. Buildings policies, directives and programmes
7. Appliances, products, lighting and ICT
8. Monitoring and evaluation: building confidence and enhancing practices












