Search eceee proceedings

M&V 2.0: Hype v. Reality?

Panel: 8. Monitoring and evaluation: building confidence and enhancing practices

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Jason Kupser, DTE Energy, USA
Sophia Francois, DTE Energy, USA
Joshua Rego, Navigant Consulting, USA
Peter Steele-Mosey, Navigant Consulting, Canada
Toben Galvin, Navigant Consulting, USA
Craig MacDonald, Navigant Consulting, USA
Kathleen Gaffney, Navigant Consulting, United Kingdom

Abstract

The roll-out of advanced metering infrastructure has created an opportunity to derive additional value from energy efficiency programs by obtaining more timely and more granular estimated impacts than those made available through traditional measurement & verification (M&V) approaches.

This paper presents two different, but related, approaches to leveraging residential high frequency energy consumption data for program management and evaluation: custom econometric analysis and third-party software tools (commonly referred to as M&V 2.0). These approaches are still relatively new, and the question remains for many North American utilities: how much of M&V 2.0 is hype, and how much is real?

One utility set out to better understand the true potential of emerging M&V approaches and to determine the relative benefit of these approaches in a deemed savings environment. To accomplish this, the company chose to pilot test both the econometric and software-based M&V 2.0 approaches to determine which represents the most effective method for performing M&V.

This paper will present the findings of this evaluation to-date, beginning with market research performed to determine the potential options for packaged “M&V 2.0” type software tools capable of evaluating residential energy efficiency programs. The paper will also discuss the structure of this evaluation, including the process of establishing program goals, identifying a testbed energy efficiency program, and selecting a vendor. Last, the paper will highlight lessons learned along the way, in the hopes that other utilities interested in testing M&V 2.0 approaches will find this information beneficial. Results from comparing traditional and M&V 2.0 methods will also be shared.

Note

This paper has already been published in the proceedings for the 2016 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 8-413-17_Kupser.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 8-413-17_Kupser_presentation.pdf