Search eceee proceedings
Energy sufficiency: how to win the argument on potentials?
Panel: 1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Charline Dufournet, Association négaWatt - Antenne de Paris, France
Edouard Toulouse, France
Yves Marignac, Association négaWatt, France
Hannah Förster, Öko-Institut, Germany
Abstract
In terms of energy demand, technical efficiency improvements alone may not be enough to tackle climate change and meet the 1.5°C target if we continue using a growing amount of energy-based services. Actions on behavioural and societal organisation changes - encompassed in the ‘sufficiency’ concept - are also required.
Energy sufficiency means efforts to rethink and redesign collective and individual practices in order to favour intrinsically low-energy activities and services, to keep us in line with the ecological limits of the planet. It requires reflecting on human needs, social equity, economic development, urban structures, social norms, consumption habits, as well as the role of policies to foster sufficiency.
There is an increasing number of contributions discussing how to take sufficiency into account in energy transition scenarios. Some energy models include quantifications of sufficiency potentials, and studies provide recommendations on how best to do it. Theoretical assessments of potentials are a key step; but making a convincing case as to the credibility and plausibility of these potentials appears to be another important matter.The reason is that sufficiency potentials are provoking specific doubts and sometimes reluctance, that may be due to their nature, limitations, and other (more or less subjective) reasons. In this paper, we propose an exploratory investigation and typology of these objections, and factors that are likely to aggravate them.
The analysis is notably based on the experience of the French négaWatt Association on the way its sufficiency-based energy scenario published 17 years ago has been received by various audiences since then. We then suggest and discuss ways to increase the trust in and acceptance of sufficiency potentials, through recommendations on how to improve their robustness and how best to communicate them (supporting explanations, effective arguments, importance of co-benefits, use of narratives, etc.).
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-248-19_Dufournet_Presentation.pdf
Download this paper as pdf: 1-248-19_Dufournet.pdf
Panels of
1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption
2. What's next in energy policy?
4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact
5. Smart and sustainable communities
7. Make buildings policies great again
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency
9. Improving energy efficiency in ICT, appliances and products



















