Search eceee proceedings

As the U.S. considers “the utility of the future”, what will be the role for utilities regarding energy efficiency and climate?

Panel: 2. What's next in energy policy?

Author:
Martin Kushler, ACEEE - American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, USA

Abstract

The electric utility industry in the U.S. is facing many challenges. These include: aging infrastructure needing major investment; economic pressure from slow demand growth; the need to integrate new technology; competitive pressures from alternative suppliers and customer-sited resources; and societal obligations from environmental, equity, and other policy objectives. There is much discussion going on about how the electric utility industry is headed for major transformation, and several leading states have begun processes to consider changes toward “the utility of the future.” (In the U.S., regulation of electric utilities is largely left up to the individual states.)

Overlaying this context is a growing awareness of the urgency of taking bold action to address climate change. The new IPCC report tells us that we have barely a decade to make dramatic changes. This highlights the critical importance of what emerges from these discussions in the U.S. Quite simply, there is no way the U.S. can hope to achieve the necessary GHG reductions without the full-fledged participation, and indeed leadership, by our utility companies in promoting energy efficiency. In the U.S., given our state-oriented regulatory structure, what states may do in this regard is of central importance. In spite of the unfortunate current lack of commitment to climate at the federal level, states can still have a tremendously important impact. In this project, we selected 7 states that have been identified in the trade press as among the leading states in terms of examining the issue of “the utility of the future”. Those states include: Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York, Ohio, Minnesota and Rhode Island.

For those states, we reviewed key documents and talked to industry experts, to gain a good understanding of each state’s approach. We focused in particular on two key areas: the extent to which their discussions are motivated by climate concerns (if at all); and the extent to which their discussion has focused on a role for utility companies in pursuing energy efficiency objectives. We also reviewed nearly a dozen reports and articles on the subject of the ‘utility of the future’ by key organizations and industry experts, to examine the prevailing thinking on this subject in the U.S. today.

To briefly summarize: concern about climate change is rarely mentioned as a motivation for the discussion about the utility of the future. Rather, the motivating factors are much more traditional: aging infrastructure; economic threats to the traditional utility business model; the need to integrate exciting new grid technology and distributed (customer-sited) resources; and the desire to maintain a reliable and affordable electricity grid.

In fairness, some of the states and industry experts do put some emphasis on integrating renewable energy into the grid (although not necessarily with an explicit climate connection). Disappointingly, however, a desire to increase utility achievements regarding energy efficiency is essentially absent from the discussions.

During the past century, the fundamental goal of the U.S. electric system has been to bring “reliable, affordable electricity” to everyone. While those traditional factors being focused upon so far in these discussions of the utility of the future are worthy objectives, they essentially ignore what arguably should be a (perhaps ‘the’) primary objective of energy utilities going forward: being leaders in the effort to mitigate climate change. Reducing GHG emissions needs to be a defining mission for utilities in the 21st century, and energy efficiency should be major emphasized strategy for achieving that. Unfortunately, what one sees so far in the U.S. in discussions of the utility of the future is primarily the application of new 21st century tools to pursue 20th century objectives.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-258-19_Kushler_Presentation.pdf