Search eceee proceedings
Investigating the energy efficiency first principle – whose idea of energy efficiency is coming first?
Panel: 2. What's next in energy policy?
Author:
Tessa Dunlop, European Commission Joint Research Centre (JRC), Ispra, Italy
Abstract
Over the past decade, the concept of energy efficiency has increasingly been conceptualized as a metaphor, as a tangible ‘fuel’ in its own right – including the invisible fuel, the fifth fuel and most recently, the ‘first’ fuel. This clarification of the concept as something tangible has been boosted by the fact it is now quantifiable in monetary terms, worth some USD $231 billion in 2016.
Since the expression 'energy efficiency first' was coined, however, the seemingly straightforward and rational terminology has taken on multiple meanings in various contexts. The European Union, for example, promotes what it calls the ‘principles’ of energy efficiency first, denoting that energy efficiency is a strategic priority. Whilst the concept of energy efficiency first has achieved valuable political consensus over an idea with which to solidify meaningful action, it has also caused political fractures.
During the trilogue negotiations of the EU’s Clean Energy Package in 2018, there was political disagreement between the Council and European parliament over how the “energy efficiency first” principle should be treated – whether as a legal requirement in national energy and climate plans, or as a slogan to honor the ‘cost-efficiency first’ principle.
Through examining the parliamentary discussions and other materials related to the Energy Efficiency Directive 2012/27/EU as a case study, this research uses discourse analysis to observe the evolution of the term energy efficiency first over time, to understand the diverse meanings and values it reflects according to the multiple contexts in which it is used, by different actors. In doing this, the analysis traces these political struggles and how they weave together policy objectives, meanings of energy efficiency and different ideas about how to implement energy efficiency policy.This presentation thus reveals both the potential as well as the dangers of the different conceptualizations of the energy efficiency first principle.
Panels of
1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption
2. What's next in energy policy?
4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact
5. Smart and sustainable communities
7. Make buildings policies great again
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency
9. Improving energy efficiency in ICT, appliances and products



















