Search eceee proceedings

Measuring the legitimacy of energy transition policy in the Netherlands

Panel: 3. Policy and governance

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Kees Vringer, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Christine L. Carabain, Sociaal en cultureel Planbureau, The Netherlands

Abstract

In line with the Paris Agreement, the Dutch Government aims to achieve a 49% reduction in CO2 emissions by 2030. Achieving this goal requires an energy transition. This transition will have a large impact on Dutch society and the business community. It is important that Dutch citizens and companies support and agree on the policies that aim to accelerate and achieve the Dutch energy transition.

This paper explores the legitimacy of these policies and how to measure the degree of such legitimacy. Policy legitimacy consists of public support for policy goals (input legitimacy) and support for the specific interventions needed to achieve these goals (output legitimacy). Policy legitimacy is based not only on effectiveness and efficiency, but also on other underlying aspects that are related to good governance. We conducted a survey among Dutch citizens and company representatives which shows there to be support (input legitimacy) for the Dutch climate policies. In other words, Dutch citizens and companies support their government’s pursuit of an energy transition.

We also explored two concrete interventions:

1) an ‘in-home display’, collectively paid for by all energy consumers, and

2) an in-home display that is paid for by the energy companies.

Both types of interventions are supported by around 50% of citizens and companies. Companies and citizens broadly agree with each other, although they are slightly more likely to support the type of intervention with the least negative impact on them.

We found strong correlations between eight underlying aspects of legitimacy and the overall support for the interventions. The eight aspects had differing levels of appreciation, depending on the type of intervention. However, in general, we found fairness to carry more weight than cost-effectiveness. We also found that public support for a particular policy goal would not automatically result in support for the associated intervention. This last finding emphasises the importance of ex-ante testing of specific interventions, to determine the related level of public support, so that policy will be more effective and efficient.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 3-182-19_Vringer.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-182-19_Vringer_Presentation.pdf