Search eceee proceedings
What is the energy saving potential for financial subsidies under Article 7 of the EED? The case of the Greek household sector
Panel: 3. Policy and governance
Authors:
Niki-Artemis Spyridaki, TEESLab - University of Pireaus Research Centre, Greece
Alexandros Flamos, School of Industrial Management and Technology, University of Piraeus, Greece
Abstract
Greece ranks very low in energy efficiency across EU countries with the household sector suffering the most from the on-going recession and resulting energy poverty levels. Governmental efforts have thus far focused on financial support programs incentivising households with lower income levels to invest in ΕΕ and the arising question is set on what are the realistic potential for these subsidies in the Greek household sector. Most efficiency potential studies for the Greek building sector have thus far provided only some rough estimates on technical savings potential.
Our assessment develops these insights further by offering a more realistic analysis of the savings potential in the Greek household sector for financial subsidies. To do so we adopt a simple bottom-up economic-engineering method to determine the impact of financial subsidies on measure-specific product sales that builds on consumer behaviour as well as evidence from past programme participation rates. This approach allowed us to include a behavioural realism aspect to our estimates of potential savings for policy induced energy efficiency measures (EEMs) which is usually not included in energy efficiency potential assessments.
We combine the results of this assessment model with engineering estimates and cost-effectiveness (CE) calculations to determine measure-specific & aggregate savings potential for alternative financial subsidy scenarios. We extend our CE calculations to include ancillary energy security related benefits and compare these benefits to inferred costs at a measure and programme level by using the Savings-to-Investment-Ratio (SIR) index.
Finally we propose a rationale for determining the final portfolio of EEMs and estimate the total programme costs and benefits for financial subsidies when implemented in the Greek residential sector and until 2030. Through a careful consideration of the wider energy-security related benefits of EEMs and by applying the SIR CE screening at a programme level, we estimate that the energy savings potential, that can be achieved by a financial subsidy may range from 3% to almost 11% of existing household energy consumption, depending on the subsidy level. When compared to programme-level targets these are more ambitious suggesting that larger-scale investments than currently foreseen are required to capture these.
From a methodological perspective, our approach is resource-intensive and underlines numerous challenges notably relevant to additionality and uncertainty in model inputs and assumptions. Despite its limitations, we consider the proposed approach to be directionally reasonable and straightforward enough to allow estimating the effect of financial incentives on the market share for the multitude of measures that are usually assessed in EE potential assessments.
The proposed assessment framework, improves our understanding on how to estimate the energy efficiency potential that can be attributed to financial subsidies and highlights the importance of including evidence from ex-post analysis into ex-ante EE potential evaluations to more accurately reflect how these will perform in the future.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 3-323-19_Spyridaki_Presentation.pdf
Panels of
1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption
2. What's next in energy policy?
4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact
5. Smart and sustainable communities
7. Make buildings policies great again
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency
9. Improving energy efficiency in ICT, appliances and products



















