Search eceee proceedings
Monitoring and evaluation of a policy is essential – what is sufficient?
Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Author:
Ulla Suomi, Motiva Oy, Finland
Abstract
From the beginning, since 1997, when the policy ‘Voluntary energy efficiency agreement scheme’ was established, it was seen that the monitoring and evaluation of the results have a critical role. Among the main commitments for companies and communities they have an obligation for annual reporting.
A well-functioning monitoring system has had a central role in revealing the results, create trust and credibility among all agreement parties and in achieving long-term top-level commitment. It has clearly been one of the success factors in the scheme. Reliable results and communication of results has led to increasing motivation and further improving results, i.e., a circle of positive development has been created.
Data gathered via a good monitoring system also gives a possibility to more robust evaluations to find out possible issues to be taken into account in the new agreement periods. While monitoring includes, in addition to the energy efficiency measures and their energy savings, also other obligations in the agreements it has also helped to report several other reporting requirements in EU reporting.
In the beginning the monitoring system served purely national purposes. During the continuation of the scheme evaluation system has evolved due to e.g. needs and requirements of EU legislation (ESD/EED). This also means that in addition to the operational costs there always need to be some resources to develop the system.
Even we have a long-lasting experience of monitoring the biggest energy efficiency policy in our country, it is sometimes a challenge how to fulfil all different and changing reporting requirements and needs. In general, should be clearly be kept in mind that it is easy to write several strict requirements for monitoring and evaluation – more grey hairs will appear to implement requirements in practice. Sometimes it seems that the pragmatic and important “keep it simple” principal is contradicting what is sufficient.
Downloads
Download this paper as pdf: 4-357-19_Suomi.pdf
Download this presentation as pdf: 4-357-19_Suomi_Presentation.pdf
Panels of
1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption
2. What's next in energy policy?
4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact
5. Smart and sustainable communities
7. Make buildings policies great again
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency
9. Improving energy efficiency in ICT, appliances and products



















