Search eceee proceedings

The pitfall of a single indicator to rule them all? Evaluation of the performance of the French housing stock in the light of various indicators

Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation for greater impact

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Marie-Hélène Laurent, EDF - R&D Département ENERBAT, France
Osso Dominique, EDF R&D, France
Fabienne Boutiere, EDF R&D, France
Stanislas Nösperger, EDF - RD, Département TREE, France

Abstract

The energy performance of a building can be evaluated with various indicators that will not give the same rating. This study evaluates the performance of the French housing stock in terms of several indicators based either on the energy stage (primary, final or energy needs), carbon emissions, or the energy bill.

An indicator calculated at the 3 stages of the energy chain allows a sequential approach to the building's performance: the "useful energy" stage measures the performance of the envelope’s, the "final energy" stage adds the performance of the equipment providing the energy services, and the “primary energy” stage associates the performance of the energy sources.

It is proposed to focus on comparing the indicators of French and British Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs).The European Union has widely disseminated the EPC for housing through the 2003 EPBD (Energy Performance in Building Directive). Originally, with the exception of the number of seven energy classes, Member States were free to choose the details of "national" EPC’s calculations. Most of European countries – including France - have chosen a scale in absolute values to define performance bands and an indicator at the primary energy stage for energy performance. UK chose on a relative scale and an indicator in energy bill.

The impact of the different proposed approaches on the evaluation of the performance of the French housing stock is analysed. The relevance of the indicators is discussed according to two criteria: the nature of the actors to whom the evaluation is addressed (households, planners, policies), and the objectives of the actions that the evaluation should guide (improvement of the housing performance, lower energy consumption and carbon emissions, reducing energy bills). As the recent revision of the EPBD requires that the energy performance of a building is expressed by means of a numerical indicator of primary energy use, this study shows here all its interest.

ERRATA

Table 1 has been corrected.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 4-105-19_Laurent_Presentation.pdf

Download this paper as pdf: 4-105-19_Laurent_rev.pdf