Search eceee proceedings

Municipal energy companies in California, Great Britain, and Germany: comparing institutional context, business models, and opportunities

Panel: 5. Smart and sustainable communities

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Laura Brinker, ECI-CREDS, University of Oxford - Environmental Change Institute, United Kingdom
Andrew Satchwell, Electricity Markets & Policy Group, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, USA

Abstract

In recent years, cities have actively engaged in supporting climate change mitigation and many local governments have established or are considering new municipal energy companies (MECs). Cities have also been motivated to increase clean energy access and help low-income and other vulnerable customer groups manage energy expenses.

In this paper we show that MECs operate in very different legislative and regulatory contexts across jurisdictions, and that this has implications for their business model opportunities and the impact they can realize. We present data from three jurisdictions: California, Germany, and Great Britain.

We first discuss key institutional differences that influence the possible range of MEC business activities. We then compare MEC business models across multiple dimensions, including value propositions, customer segments and channels, value configuration, partnerships, and revenue model. Key differences affecting opportunities to establish clean energy business models across our example jurisdictions include the opportunity for California MECs to access and spend energy efficiency subsidies, regular opportunities to purchase energy distribution infrastructure in Germany, and the use of different customer acquisition models (opt-in versus opt-out).

We then discuss the relative opportunities and potential impacts of the different MECs in terms of decarbonization, economic sustainability, and social objectives. We argue that opportunities and risks differ widely across states, and that municipalities considering establishing an MEC must, therefore, carefully assess the institutional context within their own jurisdiction.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 5-377-19_Brinker.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 5-377-19_Brinker_Presentation.pdf