Search eceee proceedings

What hinders local authorities in EU member states from financing and implementing sustainable energy investment projects? Preliminary results from the PROSPECT benchmark survey

Panel: 5. Smart and sustainable communities

Authors:
Mia Dragović Matosović, IEECP, Croatia
Niki – Artemis Spyridaki, School of Industrial Management and Technology, University of Piraeus,, Greece
Alexandros Flamos, School of Industrial Management and Technology, University of Piraeus, Greece
Vlasis Oikonomou, the Institute for European Energy and Climate Policy, The Netherlands
Katerina Papapostolou, School of Industrial Management and Technology, University of Piraeus, Greece

Abstract

The role of local authorities in national planning, as well as their effect on the achievement of European sustainable goals, is being neglected. The entire planning process stemming from the Energy Efficiency Directive (EED) is formed through a top-down approach, with countries setting goals for national policies without a sufficient understanding of which actions would be more appropriate for local authorities such as municipalities or regions to implement.

Within the framework of the Horizon 2020 PROSPECT project, a City Capacity Assessment Framework was developed focusing on city planning, financing and implementation capacity for Sustainable Energy Climate Action Plans (SECAP) related projects. The framework is intended to form a standard or point of reference (i.e. Benchmark) against which cities’ ability to attract investments, identify and utilize diverse funding sources and implement investment projects, could be measured and compared. The developed Benchmark is operationalised through an online survey including properly defined questions, assessment scales and practical city-examples reflecting a city’s overall capacity to finance and implement SECAP related projects.

The main capacity-related aspects covered in the benchmark and assessed through the survey concern a city’s local strategy and commitments, as well the legislative and economic setting framing local actions and investments as well as public acceptance issues. In terms of more project specific aspects, the benchmark assesses a city’s capacity related to phases of origination and underwriting in an investment project life-cycle as well as more general capacities in servicing investment and administration capacity. The results of over 40 cities across Europe have been collected and analysed comparatively across the different levels of cities’ progress and experience with SECAP related projects.

The analysis is supported through descriptive statistics and qualitative evidence provided by the city participants aiming to provide insights on the state of, as well as barriers and opportunities to SECAP financing and implementation at the local level.

Preliminary results suggest that a city’s progress and experience with SECAP implementation does not seem to correlate with GDP per capita, whereas a trend is obvious between the level of SECAP experience and bank lending rates. This may indicate that the nominal bank lending rate can be an appropriate means of representing general economic attractiveness at the local level.

At the same time a city’s level of SECAP experience may relate more closely with variables relevant to city capabilities and personnel availability. With regards to the latter, it appears that cities with different general institutional capacities can be successful in financing and implementing SECAP related investment projects, with the importance of educated staffing, as well as good overall cooperation with other cities highlighted through our survey findings. This points to the need for initiatives similar to PROSPECT, which cater to the need for city employees to be informed about the types of innovative financing and to make contacts with those cities which have already been successful in overcoming hurdles relevant to implementing sustainable finance solutions.

We consider the developed Benchmark to consist the first step towards an active learning process, as it enables participating cities to gain a better understanding of their state of play in relation to their peers highlighting areas for further improvement. The results of the Benchmark survey are also of value for prospect investors and finance institutions providing novel insights on general city economic attractiveness and implementation capacity in relation to sustainable energy investments at the local level.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 5-328-19_Matosovic_Presentation.pdf