Search eceee proceedings

Vehicle tax design and car purchase choices: a case study of Ireland

Panel: 6. Transport and mobility

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Ivan Petrov, University College Dublin, Ireland
Lisa Ryan, University College Dublin, Ireland
Sarah La Monaca, University College Dublin, Ireland

Abstract

On the 1st of July 2008, the motor taxation regime in the Republic of Ireland underwent a complete overhaul. Both Vehicle Registration Tax (VRT) and Annual Motor Tax (AMT) switched from being engine capacity based, to one based on carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions ratings per kilometre. The goal behind this action was to reduce CO2 emissions from passenger car use by aligning the emissions externality with the vehicle taxation system, thereby making it more expensive to purchase and operate a high-emitting vehicle. The aim of this study is to quantify the effectiveness of this (and subsequent) vehicle policy changes at achieving this goal.

Quantifying the effectiveness of such a policy change presents a number of challenges. Although the average emissions ratings of newly registered vehicles in Ireland have declined in recent years, this may also be due to vehicle suppliers offering lower-emitting vehicles, rather than a change in consumer purchasing behaviour due to the policy shift. Using a difference in differences quasi-experimental design, we attempt to recreate the missing counterfactual (in the absence of the policy change(s)) of vehicle purchasing patterns in Ireland using the trend in UK new passenger car emissions over the period.

The findings suggest that the initial policy change in 2008 is responsible for reducing the fleet average CO2 emissions rating of newly registered passenger cars in Ireland by roughly between 8 to 11 gCO2/km. Some subsequent policy changes (such as the introduction of a scrappage scheme) have also had an effect at stimulating the purchase of low-emitting vehicles. However, we find that this decrease in rated emissions is driven by a significant shift towards diesel-powered vehicles with resulting increases in other types of pollutants such as NOx emissions. This highlights the potential for trade-offs in policy outcomes unless full impact analysis is carefully undertaken ex-ante.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 6-166-19_Petrov.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 6-166-19_Petrov_Presentation.pdf