Search eceee proceedings
Energy sufficiency and wellbeing – understanding diversity and inclusion for energy reduction strategies
Panel: 1. Energy consumption and wellbeing
Authors:
Caroline Sejer Damgaard, Association for Decentralised Energy/ADEACE research, United Kingdom
Kelly Greer, The Association for Decentralised Energy, United Kingdom
Liz Warren, SE2, United Kingdom
Charlotte Johnson, University College London - Institute for Sustainable Resources, United Kingdom
Abstract
A focus on energy sufficiency and wellbeing and a call for greater recognition of equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) in the energy sector are, in many ways, two sides of the same coin. Attention to notions of sufficiency and wellbeing in the energy context could, arguably, help emphasise diverse users’ perspectives and drive more inclusive approaches to energy reduction.
Contrasting with the dominant language of energy efficiency, a technical term associated with universal measures, sufficiency and wellbeing are subjective and context sensitive notions. However, promotion of a “less is more” narrative using notions of sufficiency and wellbeing to drive demand reduction could be detrimental from a social justice perspective, if understandings of energy sufficiency – how this is understood, practiced, assessed – and how energy and wellbeing intertwine are not underpinned by a recognition of diversity and commitment to equality and inclusive practices.
Insights from a roundtable with experts from academia, policy, industry and advocacy/advice bodies highlight deeply engrained challenges, which must be addressed in order to move in this direction, but also inspiring examples to learn from and build on. The Energy Demand & Diversity: Research, Policy & Practice roundtable brought together leading thinkers and practitioners with expertise across energy, intersectionality and inclusion to discuss challenges around diversity and inclusion for energy policy and service delivery, identify gaps and next steps. Here, we introduce insights from the roundtable, with the aim to stimulate further discussion on what is needed to ensure a fair, inclusive approach to ‘less is more’ energy usage.
In terms of challenges, three key themes stand out from the discussions: 1) Terminology/understanding 2) Data, 3) Translating learning to practice.
First, terminology and understanding remains a challenge at numerous levels. Generally, the language in the energy sector is a challenge for inclusivity, with significant gaps in how energy is thought and talked about in the everyday vs. in industry/policy. Within the energy sector, participants noted a pervasive focus on income, vulnerability and households as frames for thinking about fuel poverty and energy justice, and called for greater recognition of energy users as people, “not just economic units”, and understanding of intersectional complexities.
Secondly, data was a major theme: Lack of data makes it difficult to monitor reach and impact in terms of diversity, leaving significant gaps in the evidence base for policy/programme design. There are also barriers to using what data does exist, for example due to formats or databases not being set up to facilitate analysis of EDI related questions. Sensitivities around data collection were also emphasised, with a call for guidance on best practice and methods for collecting sensitive personal data.
Thirdly, participants discussed challenges of translating research into practice and collating learnings from small, qualitative projects or trials for implementation in larger strategic projects. While there is substantial research (and data) on these topics within academic communities, it can be difficult to translate this knowledge into a real world impact, partly due to lack of funding for such activities, partly due to challenging political contexts. Fundamentally, anchoring EDI initiatives within organisations through strategic, long term focus on these challenges is essential, rather than fragmented piece-meal approaches.
Finally, while substantial challenges remain, the roundtable also highlighted examples of current practice in energy demand policy and service delivery, where EDI was successfully addressed. Of particular interest was the practice of co-design of programmes and services and principles of holistic design thinking, designing systems with the user and EDI at the centre across technical, market and governance arrangements.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-185-21_Sejer-Damgaard_SLIDES_pres.pdf
Panels of
1. Energy consumption and wellbeing
2. Policy innovations to ensure, scale and sustain action
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. A smart new start for sustainable communities
7. Policies for a green recovery in the buildings sector
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency










