Search eceee proceedings

How to ascertain a reasonable obligation level in an energy efficiency obligation scheme: between too little and too much

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Dominique Osso
Nadège Chatagnon, EDF, France
Camille Rosado, EDF, France

Abstract

Since its implementation in 2005, the French EEO scheme has gone through 4 levels of obligation and is preparing for a fifth in 2022. At each period, the consultation showed disagreements between stakeholders to specify the level of obligation for the next period. In 2019-2020 adjustments have been necessary to enable the achievement of the obligation. Different approaches could be implemented to determine the obligation:

• To set the obligation level to fulfil the requirement of the article 7 of the Energy Efficiency directive.

• To assess the necessary obligation level in order to achieve an energy policy target (e.g. carbon neutrality in 2050 and building mass-retrofit).

• To simply extend the trend thanks to sufficient historical hindsight today without questioning the context.

• To assess the technical energy-savings potentials and accessibility.

• To propose an economic analysis by taking into account market volumes and the level of financial incentive paid by all households for the investments to be triggered.

Some drawback of these methods will be discussed (energy vs. carbon target, contribution of an EEO scheme to a climate policy, lack of economic assessment or understanding of the main driver of an EEO scheme…) and comparative advantages will be presented.

The purpose of this paper is to question the different approaches to open the debate and underlines the necessity to include economic analyses to define an adequate level of obligation. A certainty is that changes in the operating conditions during the EEO period for the purpose of achieving the obligation level lead to uncertainty, and do not secure nor energy savings achievement and nor carbon savings in the long term. Moreover, a self-fulfilling obligation scenario based on price as an adjustment variable is not enough reliable to sustain the scheme. This means that a low EEO price leads to a lack of incentives for customers and a high EEO price leads to a too high cost on the energy bill.

Watch presentation

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 3-060-21_Osso.pdf