Search eceee proceedings
Car ride or beef sandwich? Impact of tracking CO2-friendly behaviour in daily mobility and eating choices in a mobile phone app
Panel: 6. Transport and mobility
Authors:
Devon Wemyss, ZHAW Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Switzerland
Manuel Grieder, Zurich University of Applied Sciences
Abstract
Consumption choices are a significant and potentially influenceable component of our individual CO2 footprint. Understanding which consumption behaviours can be shifted supports more impactful policy for addressing climate change. We present results of a behavioural intervention using a smart phone app for tracking CO2-relevant mobility and eating behaviours with the aim to uncover where CO2 savings can be achieved and what are transferable models for future scale-up.
The project, a collaboration between a Swiss energy utility developing the app and researchers, tested the effectiveness of the app in reducing mobility and eating footprints between October and December 2020. 473 participants took part in the study and were randomly assigned to receive the app or to a control group. All participants completed 3 surveys over the 6-week trial period to compare changes in reported behaviour and consumption impact awareness. As a daily tracking tool, the app provides an overall CO2 footprint score and suggests more sustainable alternatives.
Compared to the control group, those with the app significantly increased their knowledge about their consumption impact and chose more CO2-friendly food options by reducing their dairy consumption. Moreover, the app also had an impact on app users’ perceptions of and attitudes towards climate change and pro-environmental behaviour.
However, no change was seen in mobility choices. This may have been due to tightening COVID-19 restrictions and our student participants switching to at-home online learning. The reduced number of trips was noted by several participants, which highlights a certain awareness and uniqueness of the situation. As the health precautions start to relax in Switzerland, it is to be seen how mobility patterns return to their previous levels. While the positive impact on pro-environmental knowledge and attitudes of the participants is particularly encouraging, the time between their use of the app, which ended in December 2020, and increasing mobility opportunities, coming in Spring/ Summer 2021, is likely too large to have an impact on their behaviour.
The differences seen between the impact on eating vs. mobility should also be reflected on independent of the COVID-19 context, particularly considering the flexibility within the two behaviours. While eating choices are typically variable and within one’s control, mobility options can be more structurally limited or seen as a means to an end. It has been found that systematic trips tend to be easier to change as compared to ad hoc trips (the latter likely being more common during the field trial). Therefore, the appropriateness of a smart phone app, which has the particular added-value of providing feedback at the “right time and right place” in order to shift behaviour, may not be a fitting tool for more “sticky” behaviours that have limited opportunity for change.
When looking at broader mobility behaviour, a smart phone app may lend itself to address other CO2-relevant actions, besides directly reporting on the CO2 of a specific trip. For example, longer-term tracking can give insightful feedback on an individual’s mobility trends (e.g. seasonal variations, progress towards a long term goal or CO2 footprint compared to a similar person) which may support the intention to continue to work on changing the behaviour, despite its relative stickiness.
Finally, the results show that despite the disruption from the pandemic conditions, a digital approach was effective, and people had capacity and interest to address other societal issues. Thus, there are implications of using an app approach in both unique and “normal” situations. As early trends indicate that behavioural patterns are returning to pre-COVID-19 conditions, further work should address the maintenance of sustainable behaviours as we transition out of what was a considerable behavioural disruption, which is both an opportunity and a challenge.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 6-047-21_Wemyss_SLIDES_pres.pdf
Panels of
1. Energy consumption and wellbeing
2. Policy innovations to ensure, scale and sustain action
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. A smart new start for sustainable communities
7. Policies for a green recovery in the buildings sector
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency










