Search eceee proceedings

Discourse network analysis of domestic heating in Germany

Panel: 7. Policies for a green recovery in the buildings sector

Authors:
Jonas Schwenke, Switzerland
Alexandra Pröpper, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Heike Brugger, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany

Abstract

Private housing accounts for the largest share of CO2-emissions in the German building sector and more than two thirds of final energy consumption is used for heating. Gas and oil are still dominant, although there are renewable technologies available on the market. The German heating transition has gained increased attention by policy makers through the responsibility imposed by the Paris Agreement. In the past years, several policies have been introduced to mitigate CO2-emissions.

Up until now, the discourse on the heating transition in Germany has not been analysed systematically. This paper aims at identifying leading actors in the discourse and explore which argumentation is used in favour or against heating policies and technologies. We apply Discourse Network Analysis to study policy networks for the domestic heating discourse. To that end, we extract 559 statements from six German national and regional newspapers for the years 2015 to 2019. We construct different types of discourse networks and run a community detection algorithm to identify coalitions. We also compare the standing of different actor categories and the framing of concepts.

The community detection reveals no strong coalition structures but further analyses indicate opposing belief systems: Conservative, fossil-fuel-based actors on one side and social-green actors on the other. The strong lobbying for modern fossil fuel-based heating technologies might prevent widespread adoption of renewable alternatives.

Though the discourse is ideologically driven there appears to be general consensus on the necessity of CO2 emission mitigation. Most statements are given by associations that lobby for their technologies by commenting on policies. This indicates that the policy making is highly influenced by economic interests. The outcomes of the debates around the Climate Action Program 2030 show that conservative preferences dominated, even though the green party had high standing in the discourse. The greatest divide opens around discussions about the oil heating ban and the CO2 tax. Actors unanimously agree that the process of applying for heating modernisation funding lacks transparency. The findings suggest that future policies should aim at simplifying the modernisation process for end users.

Condensing oil boiler were identified to be the most talked-about and popular technology, though renewable energy solutions dominated the discourse. Negative statements about green technologies were mostly cost-framed and negative statements about fossil-fuel technologies were mostly environment-framed. Overall, both categories received mostly praise.

Over the observed time period, claims about policies and technologies are increasingly environment-framed, possibly fuelled by the climate protests in 2019. This trend spread to almost all actor categories, including fossil-fuel associations.

Overall, we see that understanding how lobbying impacts policy is important for realizing feasible climate or energy policies. Thus, it is interesting to see what policies are likely to succeed in the face of domestic political barriers. Our findings show which actors lead the discourse and which arguments they use to support their position. This information can be used to inform policy design to convince entrenched policy opponents.

Watch presentation

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-140-21_Schwenke_VID.pdf