Search eceee proceedings
Has necessity been the mother of invention? The effect of product policy on manufacturer innovation
Panel: 9. Products, appliances, ICT
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Author:
Fiona Brocklehurst, Ballarat Consulting, United Kingdom
Abstract
Product policy has long been a bedrock of energy efficiency, quietly transforming markets of appliances, lighting and other energy using equipment in a growing number of countries worldwide. The two most important policies are Minimum Energy Performance Standards, MEPS, and energy labels, together abbreviated as S&Ls. Most attention has, understandably, focused on evaluating whether and by how much these policies reduce energy use.
Nevertheless the effect on manufacturers deserves to be considered also. Manufacturers have had to respond to increasing demands to improve their energy efficiency of their products - has this driven them to innovate and increase their competitiveness? If that is the case then this could be an argument in favour of more stretching S&Ls.
There is a conceptual framework (Porter and van der Linde 1998) that suggests that this could be the case and indeed this has been found to be true of some environmental policies. But the details of the policy matter, factors such as: stringency, technology neutrality, predictability and so on.
A literature search found no meta-analyses of S&L impact on industry innovation– hence this paper is thought to be a novel contribution to the literature.
This review of the existing literature has found assessments of the innovative effect of S&Ls using two methods, econometric analysis, and case studies based on qualitative interviews. The scope of the publications is geographically broad and covers many different product groups. However, the evidence is limited and what there is does not always address the issue of innovation directly. It has not proved possible, as had been hoped, to draw conclusions about which policies have been most effective. Instead, the author makes a recommendation: for policy makers to commission and researchers to undertake more studies, improving on the sometimes less than ideal methodologies used to date and discover more on this important topic. Ultimately this could feed into the development of policies which are more effective for both consumers and manufacturers.
Downloads
Download this paper as pdf: 9-031-21_Brocklehurst.pdf
Panels of
1. Energy consumption and wellbeing
2. Policy innovations to ensure, scale and sustain action
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. A smart new start for sustainable communities
7. Policies for a green recovery in the buildings sector
8. Buildings: technologies and systems beyond energy efficiency










