Search eceee proceedings

How dynamic is consumer behaviour? A thought experiment based on agent-based simulations, field studies, and experiments

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Christian Klöckner, NTNU, Norway

Abstract

The energy transition in the European Union, but also societal transitions in relation to energy and consumption worldwide have shifted focus from technological innovation to changes in consumer behaviour and lifestyles. This inevitably raises the question, to which degree consumers are willing to engage in these transition processes, where barriers ly, and not the least, how dynamic these changes in consumption occur. This paper will explore the potential, but also the limits of changes in energy-related consumer choices based on the rich experience from several large-scale research projects: An analysis based on data from 18.000 respondents provided by the ECHOES H2020 project (www.echoes-project.eu) explores the room Europeans from 31 different countries see for behaviour change in energy- and mobility related questions and which factors impact this space of opportunity. The analyses show that the general intention to support the energy transition is high in most European countries, especially in Romania, Turkey, Portugal, Hungary and Malta (less so in Sweden, Czech Republic, the UK, and Latvia). The intention to reduce energy use for heating and cooling follows largely the same pattern, with the exception that people in countries from colder climates are less willing to reduce energy use for heating whereas people in countries from warmer climates are more willing to reduce their energy use for cooling. Intentions to buy electric bicycles and to allow the grid operators to take control about devices to reduce peak loads are lower and there is considerable variation between countries. Regression analyses show that an environmental identity, personal norms and perceived efficacy are the most important predictors of the intention to contribute to the energy transition. Personal norms and identity are also very important for the intention to reduce energy use for cooling or heating. For purchase of electric bikes and allowing control of the grid operator, an environmental identity is less important and personal norms become very important, but also social norms are more important here.

Following up on that, some examples of agent-based simulations of behaviour in relation to social energy innovations will be given from the SMARTEES H2020 project (www.local-social-innovation.eu). In this presentation, I take the case of el Hierro, were a renewable energy project was implemented (a wind-powered hydro-electric power station) and public support was varying. We simulated this varying support and different policy options to improve public support were tested. I present four scenarios, which show that increased positive communication about the hydro plant improved acceptance, especially if it focussed on more than economic benefits, and that guided tours, especially in the beginning of the project could be a powerful tool.

Finally, lessons learned from a large-scale role-out of behaviour science-informed interventions targeting energy efficiency behaviours in millions of European households in the ENCHANT H2020 project (www.enchant-project.eu) show the barriers one meets in everyday live, when trying to implement behaviour science in real live programs to initiate behaviour change. A number of issues occur when rolling out interventions large scale with real stakeholders such as translation problems of behaviour change interventions from the lab to the field, crash with company policies, crash with rules and regulations, or on-response in larger publics.

Together, the experiences from these three projects show both the potentials, but equally the limits of consumer engagement. Large changes can be achieved under the best conditions, but these are often cases where citizens already are engaged and are organized themselves.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-020-22_Klockner_pres.pdf