Search eceee proceedings

Less struggle and more thrive: How far can justice take us in guiding and understanding energy transitions?

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Yael Arbell, United Kingdom
Aimee Ambrose, CRESR, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom
Alvaro Castano Garcia, CRESR, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom

Abstract

The moral discourse around energy transitions favours justice as its main virtue, often highlighting injustice in the current system and ways to avoid it. When we aim for justice, our focus is on what is lacking. When we aim for thriving, our focus is on abundance. The current transition away from fossil fuels offers an opportunity to reinvent our energy systems and associated virtues and values. The transition must be fair and the concepts of just transitions and energy justice are a useful guide. But is justice all we should be aiming for? Drawing together theories of virtue ethics and ethics of care (Anscombe 1958, Clement, 1996), we put forward the beginnings of an alternative framework, which does not ignore justice but promotes the virtues of generosity, compassion, care and friendship as the foundations or pre-requisites of it (Beier, 2013). These virtues have the potential to bridge communities with different interests and to broaden who is part of them (Castro, 2021). These alternative virtues have the potential to give rise to new values or to revive some of those lost in the past in pursuit of ‘progress’ and to initiate an ethical chain that leads to altruism which in turn promotes justice and giving everyone what is theirs (Singer, 2015). Referring to examples from historic energy transitions, we consider the outcomes, ontologies and methods that this alternative framework might have led to. I.e. What outcomes might have resulted from the transition away from burning solid fuels in the home and towards central and district heating systems, had the transition been guided by these principles? Would we have favoured these technologies and how might we have researched and understood them? And what might a guiding framework based around generosity and care mean for the current transition away from fossil fuels?

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-031-22_Arbell_pres.pdf